Stampede Blue: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Got Chart if You Want It: Iron Bowl Comparisons

It's not the size, it's how you use it

Ack! The Colts d'not need someone like this to fix their run defense, ya bastard!
Yes, I know what the title suggests, but get your head out of the gutter and focus with me for a second. Go to any Colts message board and you'll see a gaggle of pissed off Colts fans bemoaning the Colts' lack of size. The way they make it sound you'd think they were talking about Peyton Manning's... forehead. What they are actually referring to is the Colts defensive tackles. One criticism from many pundits is the Colts lack size at the DT position. The only player with any real girth (Corey Simon) is done for the year. The current starting tackle tandem is Montae Reagor (6'3'', 285 pounds) and Raheem Brock (6'4'', 275 pounds). In a league where most defenses employ tackles ranging anywhere from 325-350 pounds, the Brock/Reagor tandem does indeed appear small.

Looks are deceiving folks.

Right now, at this moment, the Chicago Bears have the best defense in football. They had the best defense last year (12 points allowed), with the Colts coming up 2nd in points allowed (15 a game). The Bears also happen to run a Cover 2 defense, just like the Colts. Bears coach Lovie Smith is a Dungy protege. Dungy helped Lovie get the defensive coordinator job in St. Louis, which later propelled him to Chicago.

The Bears also happen to have the best DT in football: Tommie Harris. Harris is now what Warren Sapp was 5 years ago. It is week 6, and Harris has 5 sacks from the DT position. That's insane. Harris is also a relatively small DT compared to others. He is not a "space eater," like the fat bastards in New England named Vince Wilfork and Ty Warren. The Dungy "Tampa 2" defense requires the DT to attack one gap between two offensive linemen. Most defenses, like New England's, ask the DT to engage and push the o-lineman back into the backfield, allowing their linebackers to make plays. DTs for this kind of defense need serious girth, and most run at about 325 pounds.  The Tampa 2 requires its DTs to attack one gap and get into the backfield.

That's why they call this defense a "one gap" defense.

Guys like Tommie Harris play at about 288 pounds. Harris is listed at 300, but right now he's playing at about 288. This loss of weight allows Harris to use his speed to cause havoc. Montae Reagor plays at around 288, as does DT Darrell Reid (6'2'', 288 pounds). Now, there's a significant difference between what many Colts fans are demanding and what I'm asking Polian to address. I do NOT want the Colts to sign some 325 pound space eater.

DT Langston Moore
Photo: Getty Images
That's dumb. A Vince Wilfork-type player does not fit what Indy does. So, guys like Jonathan Sullivan, Lional Dalton, and Brenson Buckner can get crossed off the list. They are big, fat, and slow. Speed and quickness are a most. Corey Simon was not brought here because he was big and fat. He was signed because he is very quick for someone as big as he is. This is why the Colts made him lose 20 pounds. I'm intrigued by the Colts working out former Cardinals DT Langston Moore because he's fairly quick for a DT. He's a possibility.

The reason I want the Colts to get another DT has more to do with depth than finding a replacement for Simon. We cannot replace him this year. His loss is a major blow, maybe even a crippling one. Teams cannot afford to lose players like Simon and expect to compete for a championship. That said, the Colts cannot compete PERIOD if they only have two DTs (Reagor and Reid) playing at 288 pounds while the other two (Brock and Dan Klecko) are weighing in at 275. That's not going to get it done, especially when you consider that DT rotation is important in order to keep guys fresh throughout the year.

I hope this explains for you the difference between size and speed. The Colts need another DT that's anywhere from 285-295 pounds. We need him for depth, not to make a significant difference. This is why I'm hoping the Colts can swing a trade for Sapp. He would thrive in such a limited role, rotating him and Raheem Brock at DT. Right now, to make up for Simon's loss, the Colts need to get Bob Sanders back 100% and have guys like Reagor, Brock, Freeney, and Mathis step it up a notch.

And Polian needs to find more depth at DT.

0 recs  |  Comment 7 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Thanks for clearing that up
That was a good explination for fans, like myself, who think that a big body is what we need. I had no idea what the difference was in one gap and two gap DL scheme. That said, it seems like when our linemen hit their assigned gaps, they get in the backfield too fast and either miss the tackle or get taken out of the play without much effort by their blocker. But, wouldn't having one body to take up 2 OL in the middle help the other DL crash their gaps?

by beester on Oct 14, 2006 7:53 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Big body
The "space eater" type throws off the whole scheme. Because the oline knows they are trying to do this,it puts more pressure on them to not allow the DTs to het their gaps. This makes them focus less on the DEs, and the results are Freeney and Mathis meeting at the QB. If a space eater is inserted, a big body with no speed, then the whole thing is thrown off.

Ideally, you want someone who is both big AND fast, but such a player is very, very are. Probably the best big DT that is fast is Richard Seymour of NE. They use him as a DE, but in the Tampa 2 he'd thrive as a DT.

Simon was also big and fast, which is why he was so effective last year. Your observations on the DTs getting into the backfield and missing tackles is EXACTLY the problem. I've watched them get there and plain whiff on a guy. Stuff like that is correctable, and will help fix Indy's putrid run defense.

Please make an account and post a diary, add some comments, and make some noise. Accounts are free, and only require an email address.

by BigBlueShoe on Oct 14, 2006 10:49 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

To me...
it just seems like the linebackers are a step out of place during a run.  On a team sending the DTs through gaps, the linebackers have to be reading things better and be in the way when the runner comes, not being far enough off to the side that they get swatted out of the way on the tackle. I think when Reagor is making the tackle on a u-turn, a linebacker misread the play.

It's a weakness of the defense that the line is primarily focused on the quarterback.  The linebackers have a greater responsibility toward the run.  After seeing Thorton last week, I wonder if his loss wasn't more revealing than Simon's.  Maybe more experience at the linebacker position would be a bonus. But I like Brackett and June a lot.  So I have to blame it on Gardner.

Either way, I would be afraid to change anything.  I see teams beating themselves senseless running 200+ yards and not scoring very many points. Each game has been like a Van Damme movie--the bad guys beat the hell out the good guy for 2.5 hours and then the good guy starts making scary expressions and whipping arse for the last 15 minutes.

The Colts secondary is playing well. They are pretty thick back there.  Maybe we are seeing the mutation into a new organsim--the "Let Them Run Themselves To Death" defense.  Just keep your players in Olympic shape so they can whip arse in the last half.  

 

by will on Oct 14, 2006 8:35 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Gardner
I think it's a bit too easy to blame Gardner. Thornton played his heart out last week, and it was the best he's played all year. Prior to that, he was stinking up the Titans defense. I like Thornton, but he was not an elite LBer. And Gardner is tackling well and getting into position. I think it's guys like June, Freeney, and Brock just not taking care of business. Those guys are better than they've played, especially Freeney. He's been horrible this year.
Please make an account and post a diary, add some comments, and make some noise. Accounts are free, and only require an email address.

by BigBlueShoe on Oct 14, 2006 10:52 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Secondary
Good call on how our secondary is playing. Man, I have to mention that the only offense that moved the ball on us vertically was the Jets. And, only because Calvin Hayden was starting in place of Marlin Jackson(who was playing in place of injured Harper.) Meeks has done an unbelievable job at coaching these guys since that game against Green Bay two or three years ago. I never thought I'd say this, "Jason David is the man!"

by beester on Oct 15, 2006 12:10 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

David
Jason David has indeed played well. The entire secondary has. I'm impressed most with Antoine Bethea. Was he ever a find! Mike Doss is also playing well, though he will lose his starting job when Bob Sanders comes back.
Please make an account and post a diary, add some comments, and make some noise. Accounts are free, and only require an email address.

by BigBlueShoe on Oct 15, 2006 1:06 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Jason David
Jason David is my favorite DB, just because my fist and middle names are Jason David. Whenever I hear his name called on a broadcast I think of being in trouble with my mom back in the day. "Jason David catch that ball!!!" "Jason David make that tackle!!! heh
Steve Holt!!

by jdb on Oct 20, 2006 11:10 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Indianapolis Colts, 2006 NFL Champions!
Start posting about the Colts »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

RedZone Moments from SB Nation

Pride Of Detroit
Comcast Red Zone Recap: Week 11
Baltimore Beatdown
Ravens Game Release: Week 12 vs. Pittsburgh
Mile High Report
Comcast Redzone Report - Behind the losing streak

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
Greatest compliment ever
Bob_sanders4_small
Jerraud Powers: Old Man
Bilde_small
Sebastian Vollmer had help on Freeney 36 out of 44 passing attempts
Bruce-treetops1_small
Ask Baltimore Beatdown: Questions for the Ravens Blogger
Nnamdi_small
Why The Colts Really Won and the State of the Rivalry

Recent FanPosts

They-are-everywhere_small
injury report
Medium_jabe_small
Wednesday Injury Report
Colts_small
Bill Polian Radio interview - Fan 590 Toronto - Today Wed 11/25/09
Small
Freeney Injury
Catscratchreader_m_small
Panthers Sign LB Senn; Feedback on Senn anybody?
Peyton-manning_small
MVP: #4 for #4? Don't Count out #18!
6a00d8341c630a53ef010536a2ca2b970b-800wi_small
Peyton Manning has 42 Game-Winning Drives in his Career. (Including Playoffs)
Small
AFC Playoff Picture
No_1_small
Power Rankings - Week 12 - Final Update
Images_small
ARE THE COLTS UNDERRATED?????

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Revenge Of The Birds
Arizona Cardinals Kicker Neil Rackers Has Tweaked Groin, Team Considering Options
Turf Show Times
Random Ramsdom: Thanksgiving Edition
Acme Packing Company
Wednesday Injury Report: Packers at Lions

Head Writer, Editor-In-Chief

Stampedeblue_small BigBlueShoe

Site Editor

Bob-sanders-081107_small shake n bake

Contributing Writers

Masonair_small JakeTheSnake

Mgrex03_avatar_small mgrex03

Seyton_manning_feature_small KingRichard

Change_small Colts Homer