Jerry Jones only hires fat white dudes
![]() |
|
|
Phillips has spent the last few years building up the San Diego defense. Phillips, as a defensive coordinator, is quite good. He built great defenses in Buffalo and in San Diego. However, as an NFL head coach, Phillips has been less than stellar. His overall record is 48-42, and he's 0-3 in the playoffs. He was the head coach of the Buffalo Bills (promoted from DC to head coach after Marv Levy retired from coaching) during the Music City Miracle playoff game against Tennessee.
Phillips was chosen after an intensive 3 week search by Jones to replace Bill Parcells. Jones interviewed minority candidates like Indianapolis QB coach and assistant head coach Jim Caldwell, Chicago DC Ron Rivera, and 49ers assistant head coach Mike Singletary. All these men are accomplished assistants with impressive resumes.
All lost out to Wade friggin' Phillips, a white man with a less-than-stellar head coaching resume.
Make no mistake, Phillips was hired because he is white and a Texan. Phillips was also hired because of his accomplishments as an assistant. My question is this: what did Phillips accomplish as an assistant that guys like Caldwell and Rivera didn't? Phillips was certainly not hired for his head coaching experience. If he was, Jerry Jones is an even bigger idiot than I thought. "Head coaching experience" means absolutely nothing in the NFL. Former Dallas assistant Sean Payton had no head coaching experience, on any level, prior to getting the New Orleans job last year. Payton was Coach of the Year in 2006, leading a demoralized Saints team all the way to the NFC Championship game.
I am not the only one irked by Jones' hiring of a fat, white guy over more accomplished and more deserving minority candidates:
Why was this done? Is Jones, inherently, a racist? Maybe he is. Before you freak out and call me names, think about it for a second. I cannot recall a single black coach of any significance coming out of Dallas during the Jones era. The only coaches Jones seems to hire are white guys: Jimmy Johnson, Barry Switzer, Chan Gailey, Dave Campo, Bill Parcells, and now Phillips. Four of those six are white, southern dudes that seem to fit Jones and his mentality. Most of the top assistants in Cowboys land are white guys. Go back through their recent history: Norv Turner, Dave Wannstedt, Ernie Zampese, and Mike Zimmer. All white dudes. Heck, even the new guy Jones is "grooming" for a head coaching job (former-Cowboys QB Jason Garrett) is as white as an albino soaking in bleach.
I am not advocating for Jones or any other owner to simply hire black or Hispanic coaches solely because they are minorities. I am advocating that owners like Jones join the 21st century! Jones is a high profile owner, and if he had made a minority hiring, it would have been a real statement both from a social standpoint and from a football standpoint. There is nothing, absolutely nothing that Wade Phillips brings to the table over guys like Caldwell or Rivera. Ron Rivera re-built the Bears defense, transforming it from a laughing stock into a feared unit, minus key players like Tommie Harris and Mike Brown. Jim Caldwell's impact on Peyton Manning is enormous. Before Caldwell, Peyton Manning averaged 17 interceptions a season and was 0-2 in the playoffs. Since Caldwell arrived, all Manning has done is average only 10 INTs a season, break Dan Marino's single-season TD record, break Steve Young's single-season QB rating record, won 2 league MVPs, won Super Bowl XLI, and won Super Bowl MVP.
Knowing that, can you tell me, with a straight face, that Wade Phillips is a better head coaching candidate over Rivera and Caldwell? No, you can't. Jerry Jones is a prime example of why I really feel many NFL owners are just dumb, hillbilly hicks with little or no knowledge of how to really run a football program. Yes, I know Jones has 3 rings.
So what?
Different league, different decade, different everything. Back then, a trade like the Herschel Walker trade was possible, and Jones could essentially out spend other teams to build his dynasty. He can't do that anymore. The Cowboys have not won a playoff game in over ten years. They have only been to the playoffs 3 times in that span. Two of those appearances happened during Parcells' tenure, and Parcells is a Hall of Fame lock. Part of the reason this is so is because Jones has failed to find quality coaches and give them a chance. He could have given someone like Lovie Smith (a Texas native) a chance in 2002, or made a run at Marvin Lewis, Tony Dungy, or been creative and tried to pull a coach from the assistant ranks: Mike Tomlin, Leslie Frazier, or Gene Huey. These are accomplished men with great track records who would jump at the chance to coach the great Dallas Cowboys.
Instead, Jones retreads the same old white trash. And no, I personally do not think Jerry Jones is a racist. He's not throwing around the "N" word left and right, and spitting on black people on his way to church. I do think he is short-sighted and stupid. Actions define who you are. Actions shape perception, and right now Jerry Jones is not looking racially sensitive or open-minded. The best thing for the Cowboys and their passionate fans is for Jones to just go away. They need a fresh perspective in Dallas, not the same old recycled junk.
0 recs |
17 comments
Comments
heh
by KingRichard on Feb 9, 2007 12:56 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
His team
by memphiscat on Feb 9, 2007 4:04 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Agreed
by JasonB on Feb 12, 2007 9:50 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I find this post ridiculous.
There was no special compulsion for Jerry Jones to interview more than one minority candidate, yet he did anyways. That would be considered strange behavior for an "inherent" racist (would it matter if he were an acquired racist?).
I'd answer yes, or at least a qualified "It's possible" given his head coaching experience that Rivera lacks. Or perhaps Rivera simply had a bad attitude.
Rhetorical questions only work if you don't answer them for us, and if the question demands the conclusion you want. Nope. Nope.
Is this really necessary?
NOTE: I hate Jerry Jones more than you. I just think it's absurd to claim racism where none clearly and undeniably exists. It cheapens legitimate discourse.
by Skin Patrol on Feb 9, 2007 4:15 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
correction:
by Skin Patrol on Feb 9, 2007 4:17 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Couldn't agree more
Throwing the race card into this unnecessarily is terribly irresponsible.
Wade Phillips track record is far better than you give him credit for - especially when you take the context of both his hirings and firings into account.
In Buffalo, he was fired by a trigger happy, "championship now" front office that's run that football team into the ground. This despite, Phillips reaching the playoffs two out of three years during his time there. In Denver, Phillips never had a chance; he was simply hired as a place filler until Mike Shannahan became free from his contract with the Raiders.
Moreover, here's a stat for you: in Wade Phillips' 87 games as a coach in the NFL, he's 48-39. I dare you to go look up Tony Dungy's record in his first 87 games as a head coach in the NFL. Yup, you guessed it: 48-39.
This post is garbage. If I didn't hate Jerry Jones, too, I'd be truly upset.
by Burnt Orange Nation on Feb 9, 2007 6:27 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Philips
by Playoff Pride on Feb 9, 2007 4:38 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
over the top
i agree there are probably better coaches out there, but is phillips being hired as a place keeper again? how many good coaches (like lovie smith) are at the end of a deal next year....or does he just need someone until garrett is ready to step in? if you had a good head coach be hard to justify dumping him...
what was odd here was hiring garrett as offensive coordinator before hiring a head coach. that almost guaranteed he would take a defensive guy (which ruled out caldwell)
admitted jerry jones is about press (why else sign TO?) and is a bit of an idiot, but as mentioned earlier it is his money and his team.. you are going to have a few screwballs with money, and just have to put up with their ways.
by bluegirl on Feb 10, 2007 6:15 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
you are way off base Big Blue
Phillips is one of the few 3-4 gurus in the league and that was the biggest reason for the hire. The Cowboys defense will go from good to elite next year because of Phillips. He attacks the pocket relentlessly and his defenses always stop the run.
Hiring any offensive guys would be stupid because the Cowboys offense was very good once Romo started playing, they scored over 400 points and averaged 26 points a game. The Cowboys problems this year centered around their defense, and thats why this hire makes the most sense.
To say Jones hired Phillips because he is a Texan and white is absoutley ludicrious and stupid.
by Terry on Feb 10, 2007 12:37 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
also
by Terry on Feb 10, 2007 3:42 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Big Blue Racist
The writer obviously does not follow the Cowboys, otherwise he would know the NUMEROUS, excellent reasons why Wade was hired. I could go into them here, but it would take up the rest of my response--and I am not responding to defend Wade, but to call out this post (if u do want to know why Phillips was hired, just check out Blogging the Boys, Cowboys.com, or any of the other cowboys sites or forums--there you will find much more info that I could supply here--and just read what his former players at San Diego and elsewhere said about him). Succinctly put, his record of coming in as a DC or HC SIX times on winless teams and taking them to the plafoffs the 1st YEAR of his employment--as well as his record of dominating defenses, and winning record as a head coach--speak for themselves. Not to mention, he was the perfect fit for what Dallas needs NOW. It's pathetic how uninformed this post was.
It is truly sad that this type of blog post is the SB Nation representation that a great team like the Indianapolis Colts receives. I am glad to see that others are calling this tripe out for what it is (I hope other SB Nation representatives besides Skins Patrol read this and comment on it for what it is). When the Cowboys played the Colts earlier in the season, we had numerous Colts fans come on our forums and comment (and we Cowboys fans visited the Colts forums too). I have to say, OVERWHELMINGLY, the Colts fans were some of the classiest, most respectful, honest, and knowledgeable fans I have encountered (even if it was only via cyberspace). Furthermore, I was glad Indy beat Da Bears, and Manning finally got his ring.
Simply stated: you Colts fans deserve better than this garbage-filled racist rant.
by Wattas on Feb 10, 2007 3:56 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Horrible
For someone advocating racially sensitivity, how hypocritical is it for you to be calling Wade Phillips "white trash"? Maybe you should be the one joining the 21st century?
If Jerry Jones was racially insensitive, why did he even bother interviewing four minority candidates? This blog post is uninformed, hypocritical, and racist in its own right. You should step down from your position at SB Nation and get your head on straight.
by alienate on Feb 10, 2007 4:54 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Wow
Now, to address the issue at hand. I am sad to see what passes for "Analysis" at Stampede Blue.
Anytime one leads with a picture of someone in a nazi uniform, a klan outfit or blackface it certainly seems that you are trying to appeal to the lowest common demoniator. It's sad that after Indy's finest hour you need to go so low so fast.
Oh well.
To the point. Parcells resigned after many vacancies had been announced and filled. Dallas was facing a buffett of leftovers and interviewed a huge list of candidates. Many were retreads (Norv, Wade, etc) some were up and comers that likely weren't ready for prime time (Garrett, Singeltary) some were highly respected assistants who are frequent interviews for top jobs (Caldwell, Rivera). Some were on staff already (Sparano, Bowles). Some were from Texas (Phillips, Singeltary, Rivera). Some were African American (Bowles, Singeltary, Caldwell). One was Latino (Rivera). Some were white (Norv, Wade, Garrett, Sparano). Some were fat (Wade). One was a redheaded step child.
At the end of the day, Dallas hired a fat white guy from Texas. Ultimately his hiring had less to do with him (or his fat-white-texaness) than it had to do with the team.
Dallas finished in the top 3 in scoring despite having one of the worst feild goal percentages in the league (I know you love that). The offense was productive. The defense, on the other hand stunk. After spending 2 years revamping the team to have a big, physical 3-4 defense and replacing 6 of the front 7, we fans were promised a young swarming, aggressive defense. We got what I called "The Silver Seive."
The team had to fix the defense or get worse. So right off, Caldwell, Garrett and Turner were out. While that may reek of bias to you, its a similar strategy the Colts adopted when they hired Dungy, a defensive mided coach to get them over the hump.
That left Rivera, Singletary and Phillips.
Rivera is very talented. Still hiring him made no sense. First, he is credited for "running Lovie Smith's cover 2." He is a coordinator but not the clear architect of the defense. In his interviews he discussed a willingness to use SOME 3-4 but wanted to run some variation of the Tampa 2. If you ever watched Dallas, you would see that a defense that planned on having Roy Williams in deep pass coverage would be highly problematic. Additionally, none of the teams linebackers can drop into coverage effectively. Hiring Rivera means changing from a speed based 4-3 to a size based 3-4 to a Tampa 2 in a four year period. Forget it.
Singeltary has 3-4 experience. Unfortunately, in addition to being black, he is green. Notice that San Francisco hired San Diego's LB coach (a guy who worked UNDER Phillips) to be the 49ers DC. That's right, Singeltary now reports to him. While I pondered what Singeltary would be like as a headcoach, I think it is just too early.
This leaves Bowles and Wade. No matter what people say about Bowles, he was the secondary coach for an extremely BAD secondary. Sorry, not good enough. Now Wade... He runs a great 3-4. If he gets it done, we keep him, if not we hire Cowher. If that happens, I guess you will call Jerry a racist again...
Oh Well. Now as far as coaches, we have had a lot of African American assistants (Tolbert, Carthon, Bowles, etc.) however that is less a statement about Jerry than it is about Parcells, Campo, Gailey, Switzer and Johnson.
by 325424 on Feb 10, 2007 6:43 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Phillips
by MasterRWayne on Feb 10, 2007 8:02 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
This one time
?
by Skin Patrol on Feb 11, 2007 11:32 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
3-4
by MasterRWayne on Feb 10, 2007 8:07 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
defensive guru
he may be a great defensive coordinator but he hasn't got it to be a head coach.
i honestly wondering if jones has someone else in mind and is just hiring phillips as a place keeper for a year or two... and to help build up the defense until that point....
by bluegirl on Feb 11, 2007 7:11 AM EST reply actions 0 recs

by 




















