Recap 2007 Pre-Season: Bears 27- Colts 24
![]() |
|
|
In lue of the ST horror show last night, I have to say I'm done with Russ Purnell. I'm just done with the guy. He's had six years to develop the Colts special teams into something resembling a professional football unit. And yet year, after year, after year this unit stinks. No, it's not because he only has young guys to work with. All teams use young guys on special teams. Chicago has young guys on special teams, and last night special teams was the only thing Chicago did right. The Colts held numerous practices during Training Camp specially working on special teams. They stress it year, after year, after year.
And yet, the results are the same.
Because of this, I gotta point my finger at the coach, Russ Purnell, and say I'm done with him. Dungy should fire him right now, promote someone from within, and get this damn thing fixed. I understand that change at this point might cause a ripple effect, but any change is better than seeing the Colts special teams allow scrubs like Daniel Manning torch the team with a BS return.
Ok, that's the negative. Now, the positives!
- Ed Johnson is developing into a fine player. He is the unquestioned starter at DT and continues to improve. Again, maybe Booger's injury was a blessing in disguise.
- The defense was electric. People flew to the ball, made hits, and tackling like demons. Marlin Jackson is now better than Nick Harper, and would have started this year over Harper even if Nick was re-signed. Marlin "rodeo" tackle of Devan Hester for a 2 yard loss provoked a "F*&k yeah!" out of me when it happened. His pick on Grossman was also quite good. Marlin is a stud.
- Freddie Keiaho still continues to show he's a better linebacker than Cato June. First play from scrimmage, Grossman hands off to Benson. Benson is greeted at the LOS by Keiaho. Benson drops like a sack of bricks. I spied Freddie all evening while he was in there, and he was always around the football, making tackles and disrupting plays.
- Anthony Gonzalez is FAST. They need to feed him the ball more with the first unit in a 3 WR set, because when he gets the ball he's the Flash.
- Tony Ugoh played solid, and continues to improve. He's much more comfortable run blocking. In the second quarter he laid a vicious block to spring Joseph Addai for extra yardage. On passing downs, he was improved but only decent. Ryan Diem was the one who was bad last night.
- I'm now a big Matt Giordano fan. He can't cover, but the man can tackle, hit, and runs, runs, runs. He was the only one tackling on special teams, and he made a great play on a screen pass preventing a first down.
- Kenton Keith and Clifton Dawson played better than DeDe Dorsey. I expect to see them more in the third game.
- Cut Jim Sorgi. He's terrible. Yes, he was good late in the second half on one drive. After that, he was bad to overthrowing wide open receivers, getting picked off, and generally scaring the crap out of us Colts fans. On the other side, Brian Greise looked sharp, accurate, and he didn't have near the talent around him that Sorgi did. Like Purnell, I'm done with Sorgi.
- TJ Rushing might just have lost his starting returning job. Fumbles in situations like last night get you the Ricky Williams treatment. No, not THAT Ricky. The other Ricky Williams, a running back the Colts traded for back in 2003. He started one game against the Panthers four years ago. He had two costly fumbles in that game. He never started again, and was eventually cut.
Despite the special teams play, everything else was very good. I have to say, MNF, while improved with Jaws in the booth, is still pretty painful to watch and listen to. Tony Kornheiser is terrible, and is approaching Dennis miller critical mass. He isn't funny. He's annoying. And he doesn't know jack squat about football. So what's he doing in the damn booth? And no Bob Kravitz, it's not Michelle Tafoya's job to ask Peyton Manning about Michael Vick. Yes, Manning was annoyed she asked him, and for good reason.
No one cares what Manning thinks of Vick.
Vick's guilty. We all know it. We all move on. Goading Manning on Vick's plea is the same "gotcha journalism" that makes people turn the channel. No one cares what other players think of Vick, and no one cares for Michelle Tafoya. Female sideline reporters are there to look hot, smile, and offer viewers something else to look at than a fat offensive lineman or Kornheiser's bald head. They aren't journalists or reporters. They are eye candy, pure and simple. I personally would have no problem if TV did away with all sideline reporting. The only news worth anything from Tafoya's question is if Manning went off on a tirade bashing Vick, which you know he isn't going to do. We only care what the law and the NFL will do to him.
As always, thanks to the great Bears fans over at WCG. Though the Bears have a strong defense and special teams, Rex Grossman is awful (3 fumbles, 1 lost, 1 INT) and Cedric Benson is a major bust. I don't say this to piss of Bears fans, but after watching those two that night I see they haven't changed since last year.
0 recs |
26 comments
Comments
Kravitz...
The coverage last night was horrible. It took 20 minutes of Monday Night Countdown before they even mentioned the Colts and Bears. They also stopped in the 2nd quarter when Sorgi was in for about 10 minutes to talk about Vick and didn't even mention that a game was going on. Some people actually care about the backups and want to see how they are doing.
by the21eraser on Aug 21, 2007 10:54 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Noose is a bit over the top
Rushing took a pretty good hit in an awkward twisted up position - I think he'll be fine.
Ugoh got run around on during passes with the 1st team defense out there. Manning was covering for him big-time, but I think he'll improve as the year goes on.
I think they would be better with Booger, at least from a depth perspective, but at least the defense looked good. Giordano was awesome. Special teams is going to cost the Colts a game or two this year.
I'm still wondering who is going to step up and run well behind Addai.
by SteveW on Aug 21, 2007 11:07 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Also...
by SteveW on Aug 21, 2007 11:10 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Manning on SNL
by shake n bake on Aug 21, 2007 12:59 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I'll have to respectively disagree
The out and out fumble by Grossman was great defense by you guys. One botched snap was Kreutz's fault. Yeah, I said it. The other, possibly, but I couldn't really see. The INT was a bad play, but running a drag with Rashied Davis is the stupidest play call on the face of the earth. They were testing out your rookie and he won that battle. Big deal.
Lots of Bears fans will call for Griese to start just like last year, but I'm not going to throw him under the bus until after game three, at the earliest. We would still have plenty of time to win the division, especially since the Lions, Vikings, and Packers all suck royally...
Also, your special teams might suck and all, but they went up against the best special teams unit in the league, so it was a good exercise for them. Maybe it will make them better. You should be glad you had your weaknesses exposed now, rather than by Maurice Jones-Drew in week 7.
by mikebdot on Aug 21, 2007 1:08 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Benson and Rex
Rex is a different story. If anything, he's just the wrong QB for your team. With the defense and special teams that the Bears have, they don't need a prolific offense to win a championship. Sometimes, they don't even need an offense at all (a la Arizona last year). They need a Trent Dilfer kind of guy. A guy who understands that it's not his job to go out and win the game. He just manages the offense, minimizes his own mistakes, and doesn't loose the game. Why score 30 when 17 will do the trick? Griese is that guy. He's smart, knows his limitations, and manages the game well. The only problem with Griese is that he's a band-aid. He's injury prone and on the downslope of his career. And the Bears would destroy Rex if they benched him and later if Griese got hurt and Lovie said, "Hey guy, we need you." That in itself is the biggest problem with Rex, in my opinion. He's "fragile". He projects false confidence, and forces throws that aren't there because he's too busy trying to prove that he's the guy. If I were a Bears fan, I'd be afraid that by the time Rex works out his mental issues, if he ever does, that the window to win a championship will have closed.
by rudy0498 on Aug 22, 2007 12:32 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I don't want a
Another reason I'm willing to give him a chance this year is because our team is stacked for the immediate future. If Grossman can work out the kinks this year and realize his potential I honestly think there is no way we don't win 3 of 5 super bowls the next five years. Our team is young, with the exception of the O-line and our draft picks have been so good recently I have no doubt we won't be drafting at least two of them next season to capably fill in the voids. If he can't fix his problems I feel Griese is a great backup and will be that "trent dilfer type" guy. By the way, how is Dilfer doing these days anyway?
http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/DilfTr00.htm
I'm not sure that is something we should aspire to. Shoot, even Tampa gave him TWO terrible years behind center before he became "servicable".
by mikebdot on Aug 22, 2007 12:50 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Dilfer....
Grossman has more than a few kinks. The guy honestly reminds me of Jeff George minus the whining. He has all the physical tools and has the ability to make every throw on the field. But he just can't get out of his own way. He's too busy trying to be a "gunslinger" like Favre. But doesn't have the short term memory loss to be successful at it. For every Brett Favre, there are 20 Jeff Georges. The fans and the media have already beaten to a pulp, and he'll never gain confidence to turn it around.
3 to 5 super bowls? Really? C'mon....you are projecting your team 5 years into the future with the competitive balance in today's NFL? Our team is pretty young too and just won the Super Bowl, and even I would be delusional to make that statement.
by rudy0498 on Aug 22, 2007 3:57 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Dude, your defense sucks
My job as a fan is to be excited about the talent I see, and I see more talent on the Bears than I've ever seen. That's right, I think we have as much talent as the '85 Bears. Even WITH Rex at QB. I've never made that claim in the 20+ years since.
I think Rex could either be good, or not. It doesn't really matter. Look at how he played last season. If he has a carbon copy season of last year we still go 13-3 and make it to the SB. Maybe the balls bounce our way that night. Heck, we could go 11-5 with the way he played last season without needing our awesome ST and defense. But we still have those guys and sitting pretty.
by mikebdot on Aug 22, 2007 5:19 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Your QB...
I remember Manning getting alot of abuse because we couldn't win the big one. I'd get so mad. A whole lot of good QB's never won a ring, including many current ones, but Manning took it on the chin for it. It's because he's great, so the expectations are high.
That is why Grossman is getting ripped more than the myriad of lousy Bears QB's before him. It's because he is great, but nobody is patient. Mark it down, he will have his ring(s). It's still early.
by coltsfanawalt on Aug 23, 2007 3:23 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
He might get his rings ...
by PaytonMenning on Aug 23, 2007 9:49 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
On that..
If he does play well and happens to win a ring, the media will jump off his back and maybe he can be allowed to be a great player. I just hope to Halas he has 15 INTs or less this season. Preferably not all in 5 games, just to shut everyone up.
by mikebdot on Aug 23, 2007 10:28 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I live in Chicago ...
by PaytonMenning on Aug 23, 2007 11:40 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I also want to point out
http://www.nfl.com/players/trentdilfer/gamelogs?id=DIL049692&season=2000
He went up against Kerry Collins and the Giants. Their defense was terrible and Kerry Collins was a drunk. The Ravens had 10 INTs in 3 playoffs games. He threw 1 during those three games. Lucky him. The competition was terrible.
Also, in the regular season he started 8 games, played in 11, and threw 12 TDs and 11 INTs. Those stats look very similar to Rex's 23/20. Yes, Rex had more bad games, but he had more great ones too. I'm not sure why anyone would fault a Rex supporter when they truly hope that he can simply eliminate the bad games. If not, put in Griese, the game manager extraordinaire and be prepared to be bored while watching offense. Screw that. Ron Turner could simply ask Rex to be a game manager and I'm sure he'd turn into one, but that's not how he rolls.
by mikebdot on Aug 23, 2007 11:53 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
actually
2 of those 10 picks were returned for scores.
by mikebdot on Aug 23, 2007 11:54 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Also
by mikebdot on Aug 21, 2007 1:11 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
anyone else
by yellowsnow on Aug 21, 2007 1:28 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
mikebdot
I also notice that you call many other plays "some other guys fault" or "a stupid play" - like the drag with Rashied Davis, why is the the stupidest play on earth? Maybe if Grossman had bought the time for Davis to move into the drag, and not try to hit him on the turn (when the corner also is going to be watching the QBs eyes in case of a post or inside slant route as opposed to the drag) that play would not have been made. Marlin simply made the play his position would call for held onto the play. I call that a solid defensive play that took opportunity the offense game up.
And although you have history on your side when it comes to your NFC North comments, don't speak your judgements too quickly, as two teams in the division might present quite a bit more of a challenge than they did last year.
Also, in your second post, you have to give me a break. Faulting Giordano for where his assignment was? Yeah, he probably could have had a chance 10-15 yards earlier but the Bears have a great return team as a whole, and also Giordano doesn't exactly have Hester speed.
by Bullard47 on Aug 21, 2007 3:08 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
CB is a beast
The drag to Rashied Davis is stupid because he is 5'9" and about 175 lbs. At most. The guy in the slot running a drag for a 1st down catch should be big. It really should have been a tight end. I don't like Davis very much. He made two big catches last year and that was it. He runs up the seam quickly, like every other receiver in the league. Big deal.
I'll speak my judgements as I see fit. If we went 0-3 history is on my side that we could start Griese and go 9-7 and win the division. Jon Kitna sucks way worse than Grossman, even on a "bad rex" day. Favre is too old and has no talent around him. And Minnesota is just a joke, except maybe their defense. We'll see in due time.
How do you know what Giorano's assignment was? Seriously. Maybe it was to tackle him at the opposing 30. That's all I'm saying.
by mikebdot on Aug 21, 2007 3:30 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Out of curiosity
Kitna: 4208 yds, 62.4 comp %, 79.9 rating, 21 TD/ 22 INT
Grossman: 3193 yds, 54.6 comp %, 73.9 rating, 23 TD/ 20 INT
Kitna was better in every major category with the exception of TD/INT (and those were pretty close). Kitna also wins in more inside-the-numbers categories like yards per attempt (7.1 to 6.7). I know the Lions threw more than the Bears last year, but that doesn't explain Kitna's superiority in things like comp %, rating, and yards per attempt. It seems to me that Kitna is better than the average of Rex's season; yet you claim that he sucks worse than Rex even on Rex's bad days.
I'm not even being snarky, I'm curious as to what support you have for that postion, beyond an obvious bias for Rex.
by ctnyc on Aug 21, 2007 11:39 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Well, as it turns out...
I have some amount of faith in Rex and hope to Halas he fixes this latest "issue" (which, after looking at the first fumbled snap was clearly Kreutz's fault, go to chicagobears.com and check out the highlights from the game, the ENTIRE offensive line moved), but like I say, Griese is capable of at least going 9-4 to finish the season, especially playing in our division...
In any event, I'm frontin' quite a bit. I'm mildly worried about the Lions, but it's the same thing every year. They draft a wideout, he's a bust, and life goes on. I swear, they have THE worst luck (aka Matt Millen). Honestly, it's almost a certainty that Johnson will be a stud, but there will be a freak injury and he'll be out for three years. I would almost best money on it...
by mikebdot on Aug 22, 2007 11:52 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I disagree...
Don't get me wrong, Hester would win a 40 yard dash, and he's way more agile and has better acceleration, but Giordano is pretty damn fast if you're just running in the open field.
by the21eraser on Aug 21, 2007 3:37 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Hester let up
by mikebdot on Aug 21, 2007 4:12 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Life is good . . .
by shonuff on Aug 21, 2007 3:20 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Take it easy on Rushing ...
by PaytonMenning on Aug 22, 2007 10:30 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Very true..
by the21eraser on Aug 22, 2007 11:10 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 






















