I will agree with you that Marshall would certainly boost us to the top 1 or 2 in the Power Rankings, but he’s no Randy Moss. Would I like to see a guy like Marshall lining up across from Reggie? Absolutely. Do I think he’d be very successful in our system? Yes. Do I think the experiment would work like Moss in New England? Not at all.

Reason? Well, Randy Moss was an outstanding teammate prior to his time in Oakland, and an outstanding teammate afterwards. Marshall had problems off the field even with Cutler at the helm and if there’s anything Indy sports fans hate from their atheletes, it’s problems off the field. Plus, as proven time and time again, BP goes for home-grown talent and rarely (if ever) goes after a big name free agent.

and I nearly shat myself. Do NOT do that to me. .

could use somebody like Marshall, opposite Holt
Garrard needs all the help he can get at wr.

Did you play football? I wonder.

I’m a COLTS fan. You probably hate Mike VIck too. I believe people deserve a 2nd chance. Who are we to judge. We have no idea how these guys were raised or where they come from. I know that dog fighting is really big down south. Not saying its right. Cuz it is disgusting to treat any animal like that. He did his time for that. Plaxico certainly did not deserve 2yrs for shooting himself. When you only get 24 days for killing someone. Looks personal to me.

He is on a team that is self destructing. No one is mad at Jay Cutler for demanding a trade. No one is mad a Eli Manning when he refused to go the Chargers. I agree he made some mistakes he is only 25. Do you remember when you where 25? Again, the Colt’s organization is stable. Remember Randy in Oakland. I think Brandon would have a huge impact for the Colts. Becuz we have Peyton. No dbl coverage on Wayne. More running lanes for the RB’s and both WR are big and physical so short passes become big gains. Which kills the blitz. Understand I have played football all my life. Former U of M player and San Diego St. I learned from some pretty impressive coaches. So again this guy is the real deal. To answer the question about Plex. Gun law may be strict. What about killing someone? that has to be worse.

We can sign him becuz he wants a shot at a superbowl. Plus again, we have the best QB in the league. So we use him for a year. And then we could franchise him or let him go. But he is only making 2.2 million right now. All denver wants in 1st rd pick

Mr Marshall is now a locker room cancer. You are certainly a hater. And have never played any organized football in your life. Stop watching TMZ and know the facts. People said the same thing about Ray Lewis, Randy Moss, Steve Smith. and they are all pro-bowlers. Stop hated player. It’s obvious you are perfect. And Moss did have a great QB in Minnesota. Dante has a strong arm that benefited Moss. But again Moss and Rice two different types of receivers. Rice went over the middle Randy does not. Rice ran reverses, randy does not. So he is not Rice and Rice is not randy. Randy still has work to do. But, he is a beast. Don’t hate the player. Hate the game.

Marshall never had any problems with other team member. Randy moss admitted to the world on tv that he smokes marijuana. that was real stupid. Not to mention that he initially signed with Florida St. out of H.S. but the weed got him in trouble there. To the fan who said Marshall is nothin without cutler, was randy anything in Oakland. I’m not related to Marshall, but I have been around numerous guys in the league. Az Hakim that used to play for the Rams was my roomate in college. So I have been around a lot of receivers. I have seen Brandon Marshall in person. The guy is a hell of an athlete. And he is a good guy. People just read all the tabloids and make there own assumptions. But, you don’t really know them as a person. Plus I never said he was Randy Moss. I just said that people wrote Randy off in Oakland and I was happy to see that he proved all the haters wrong. Just like everyone is hating on Brandon Marshall. Hell, randy was traded for a 4th round pick. Cheers to the Pats.

I just want the colts to pull off what the Pats did. Get a great player who will help you win a super bowl. The colts are a great organizaion and would help him mature. I see how everyone hates him. Just like moss was in Oakland. Just like Vick. And the situation with the cop. Hey I was not there. I know some cops have chips own there shoulder about athletes. But, yeah it was stupid. But I dont knw the facts.

I am not saying everyone is a hater. But when you say a guy is a cancer. That’s pretty personal to say about a person you don’t know. Hey Steve Smith has broke some players faces in the locker room. But he’s not called a cancer. I’m saying know the facts before passing judgement. Thats all

and I think it’s pretty clear,
the majority don’t want him on our team.

but apparently were all “haters”
none of us have any football knowledge
and apparently everybody that doesn’t think Marshall
would be a good fit for the Colt’s, hates players like
Mike Vick, Randy Moss, etc.etc.

Wow!!!

In sports the media are sharks. They bring up everything. So yes the media would bring up his fighting. And Steve Smith does have a temper. But he is very passionate about the game of football. So yeah it would be brought up. To Mr Payne I said the if you make a personal comment about a player you dont know. Then yes you are a hater. I simply said that randy moss was labled a bad seed a few years ago. And you see what happened. All I said is that he would be a different player with the colts. Why did Rodman and Jordan work? And you cant say the rodman was not a screwed up individual. And I’m only saying that becuz he did not try to hide it. But when you have veterans on your team. They will show him the right way. I don’t expect for you or anyone else to understand. I know from experience. And I’m sure the colts know to. Ask Ed Johnson.

I’d give the Broncos a 3rd for Marshall. Mainly because Polian whiffs on those every year.

Normally I wouldn’t be in favor of taking a diva like Marshall, but he’s got undeniable talent, and I can’t imagine him acting up when he’s got Manning throwing him passes. Moreover, I can see him being brought in by Polian & Co. and told “You’re on an exceptionally short leash. Screw around, and no one will touch you, because if you can’t win here you can’t win anywhere. Do things our way, and we’re talking Super Bowl. Up to you, kid.”

Gonzo would be our wes welker

I think most everybody agrees that he has talent, but your not going to be able to bring a guy like that in and stay under the salary cap most likely. The Colts had to juggle the numbers around just so they could keep Jeff Saturday, which they definitely need to keep. And I’d really hate to see the Colts trade away a first round draft pick or possibly more for him. I’m really interested to see how Austin Collie will do. I think Collie has a lot of potential, more than most give him credit for.

I just don’t see Irsay allowing any more money spent on expensive players that are not drafted. Remember the Cory Simon problem. He cost the team plenty of cap money after leaving the Colts for unspecified reasons.