Peyton didn't deserve the MVP in 08 and 09?

Thank god you aren’t an asshole! Who gives a shit what Kerry Byrne thinks? I hate guys named Kerry!

Cold Hard Football Facts, the winners in the “Let’s make up stats to make Tom Brady look Great and Peyton Manning bad” game. I wouldn’t waste 30 seconds reading his “objective” viewpoint.

Man if My die hard Saint fan newphew and diehard Pat fan ftrom Childhood can not argue against Manning getting the award , nor my cynical brother, then no one can

Peyton will have deserved all his MVPs. If you are looking at just the criteria of a player who is the single most valuable member to a teams success, then there is no question its Manning. This past year Brees had a legitimate argument too, but he had his full corps of receivers, Manning didn’t. Thats why QBs are winning it more than any other position. It is difficult for even a Chris Johnson to justify being the single most important key to the success of his team when he is only responsible for or facilitates only half of the offenses production. QBs set up the run plays, and call plays at the line, and no one is more valuable at playcalling, setting up the run, and getting the football where it needs to go than Peyton Manning. If a team like Carolina wins 13 games this year on the back of their QB, then he’d deserve it, but in 2008, and 2009, it was obvious that there was no strong competitor against Manning for justifiably being the, “Most Valuable Player,” on any team.

that guy is a bigger douche than Florio. Just another butthurt Pats troll.

also, if they just vote for him regardless if he deserves it or not then why did he go from 1998-2002 and then 2005-2007 without winning one?

I KNOW there is a reason I don’t like Aaron Rogers as much as CH or LovinBlue (she has her reasons…. they are from the same school).

Peyton Manning or Tom Brady? Green Bay Packers QB Aaron Rodgers said Brady “is the best by far” among current NFL quarterbacks. “It’s not even close,” Rodgers told ESPN Radio.

Welll…. that definitely calls his intelligence into question. We can call out the analysts as much as we can, but from a pre-sumed “great” QB like Rogers?? and oh, it’s not even close…. he must have some brain damage while he was being sacked all those times. During a poll of HOF QBs,

Voting results
For Peyton Manning: (13½ votes)
Troy Aikman (Class of ’06), George Blanda (’81), Len Dawson (’87), Dan Fouts (’93), Bob Griese (’90), Sonny Jurgensen (‘83), Jim Kelly (’02), Warren Moon (’06), Joe Namath (‘85), Clarence (Ace) Parker (’72), Fran Tarkenton (’86), Y.A. Tittle (’71), Charley Trippi (’68). Joe Montana (’00) (second half)
For Tom Brady: (2½ votes)
Terry Bradshaw (’89), John Elway (’04), Joe Montana (first half)
Abstain: Dan Marino (’05), Bart Starr (’77), Roger Staubach (’85), Steve Young (’05)

I don’t know, somehow somewhere, something tells me Rogers needs help…. (cue attacks from Rogers homers).

Jared Allen is a very good player, but he would not be the non-OB mvp. I recall a post here that proved Freeney was better than Allen against better competition with more consistency. And how could Peyton not deserve those MVP’s, if you watch any game in 2009, you could tell he was freakin amazing, lead several comebacks. We got so used to it, we expected it to happen every time. And in 2008 after a horrible start he leads us to nearly a division title. Does this guy have an editor? Surely, he would have thought this guy was crazy, like any other sane, intelligent person would.

I understand the underlying premise of his article; he’s just tired of seeing big name quarterbacks always win the MVP award. I can empathize with him on that, except when it’s Peyton winning it of course.

The problem I have with his article is the fact that Jared Allen is arguably one of the most overrated players in the league. If we really were to have a non-QB MVP vote, Allen wouldn’t have won last year anyways because there was this stud named Darrelle Revis ripping it up all season long.

As for 2008, there wasn’t a single defensive player that stood out aside from Asomugha, that I can recall anyways. Besides, Peyton blew everyone out of the water in 2008. If you recall, the person with the second most votes for the real MVP award was Chad Pennington and Michael Turner, with a whopping four votes each. So in my opinion, homer pick or not, Peyton was most deserving.

Again, I understand what he’s trying to say, but glorifying Allen the entire article and saying he deserves to be in the same universe as Peyton when it comes to his impact on a team is lunacy.

Manning is over rated. He is a great QB but he don’t run the #1 offense. Brees does , and he has for 4 years now. Brees has better numbers then Manning every year.Manning has been some what of a playoff bust too. Remember too that Manning has been there 12 years now and has only won (1) super bowl. Brady has won (4) in less years. Brees has (1) in only 4 years. If you go by Percent’s then Brady and Brees are better. Plus , Brees just won the super bowl against Manning. Brees also took the MVP there. Seems like the top 3 are Brady then Brees then Manning. So yes a lot of people think Manning is over rated and they simply put his name on the MVP where ever they make the thing. If they would vote after the super bowl every year we would have a better winner , more fair. But 12 years and one super bowl win ? Thats not that great , see> Steelers,49’s,Patriots for the dominate use to be teams other then the Pats cause they are still up there.