Countdown to Colts Training Camp 2010: Reviewing and predicting the key position battles
Camps all throughout the NFL are opening, and the Colts will get their own started this Sunday at the University of Anderson. As camp approaches, we shall use today's slight lull in news to review the key positional battles that will shape and define our favorite team not just for the pre-season, but for the entire regular season.
Camp battles last year produced quality starters like Daniel Muir, Pierre Garcon, Austin Collie, and Jerraud Powers. In years past, positional battles helped forge players like Antoine Bethea, Gary Brackett, and Robert Mathis. This year, we have several camp competitions that are sure to spark tremendous interest in the team's practices and activities in Anderson. Many of these battles have been hotly debated on this blog since late-April. Others have been brought into the team fold because they fit the new shifts in the team's offensive philosophy, especially along the offensive line.
After the jump, we break down the camp competitions, discuss the key players involved, and make our predictions on who is going to win what job.
Starting guards
As of right now, we have absolutely no idea who will start at left or right guard for the Colts in 2010. Ryan Lilja is gone; cut seemingly because his 290 pound playing weight was too small for new offensive line coach Pete Metzelaars' vision moving forward. Logically, it stands to reason that the Colts are looking to have two 300-plus pound guys man the guards spots. If not, then cutting Lilja in March makes absolutely no sense, especially if his replacement is either Kyle DeVan (6'2, 306) or Mike Pollak (6'3, 301). Both offer marginal size over Lilja, and both are inferior players.
If size at the guard spots is the goal, then new additions like Jacques McClendon (6'3, 324) and Andy Alleman (6'4, 310) offer significant size and height over Lilja, DeVan, and Pollak. With the team tossing in former-starting left tackle Tony Ugoh (6'5, 301) and reserve tackle Adam Terry (68, 335) into the mix, the "beef" increases substantially. It seems obvious that the Colts will go with whichever two guards work the best within the Colts system. However, if both of those guards do not offer additional size or weight over Ryan Lilja, the question will linger as to why the excellent veteran guard was cut.
Stampede Blue prediction: McClendon and Terry win the jobs.
Slot receiver
Once again, we enter a Colts training camp with Austin Collie having to fend off someone to win the slot receiver position. Last year, Collie beat out Pierre Garcon. This year, he is battling Anthony Gonzalez, the man who has seemingly lost his starting job to the before-mentioned Pierre Garcon. Gonzalez entered last season as the replacement starter for the departed Marvin Harrison. However, Gonzo's season was cut short by a frustrating knee injury in Week One. Replacing him in the starting line-up was Garcon, who wisely took advantage of the opportunity and had a breakout season.
Also thrown into the slot receiver mix is Samuel Giguere, but at best Giguere is a good special teams player. The real competition is between Collie and Gonzo. In 2009, Austin Collie had a Rookie of the Year-type season (despite not getting a single vote from the seemingly brain dead voting panel). He caught 77 passes for 917 yards and 10 TDs with his best game being a 7 catch, 123 yard, 1 TD performance in the AFC Championship Game against the NY Jets. Collie's 2009 season crushes anything Gonzalez ever did in his two seasons prior.
However, this does not mean Gonzo is a chump.
According to Football Outsiders, the third best receiver in all of football in 2008, on a per-throw basis, was Gonzo. Without getting into a bunch of brain-smashing numbers, it basically means that anything thrown at Gonzo was caught by Gonzo. Along with his reliable receiving skills, Gonzalez has exceptional quickness, speed, and is a sharp route-runner. On most NFL teams, Gonzo is a starter. On the Colts, he's fighting for the third WR spot.
Stampede Blue prediction: Collie
Dime defensive back
You know you are rooting for a stacked team when a key camp battle is who will play in the Dime Package on defense. However, as talented as starting corners Kelvin Hayden and Jerraud Powers are, and as reliable as nickel back Jacob Lacey seems, history tells us all three of these guys will likely get injured during the regular season. These injuries will result in missed games, meaning the fourth or fifth corner on the roster will either need to start a game or play as the nickel back. Ideally, we'd love it if Powers and Hayden started every game, but since 2007, Kelvin Hayden has only started 18 of 32 regular season games. Last year, Jerraud Powers missed 4 regular season games and was hurt all throughout the playoffs.
Again, history tells us these guys will. get. hurt. in. 2010.
Working behind nickel back Jacob Lacey on the depth chart are an assortment of rookies and second-year, practice squad-level guys looking to make the team. Of the bunch, seventh round pick Ray Fisher, rookie free agent Brandon King, and second-year player Terrail Lambert offer the most potential. All three have the skills sets necessary for them to stay on the active 53-man roster. Key to this secondary performing well in 2010 is for the coaches to produce another surprise player similar to Jacob Lacey. Last year, Lacey entered camp as an no-name, undrafted rookie. By the time Super Bowl 44 rolled around, Lacey had started 9 regular season games, intercepted three passes, and returned one for a touchdown. The Colts will likely need a similar level of production from players like Fisher, Lambert, or King.
Stampede Blue prediction: Fisher
Special teams returner
The Colts have been awful at punt and kick returns since T.J. Rushing injured his knee in a 2008 pre-season game against the Buffalo Bills. Since then, the Colts have brought in a carnival of players, hoping one of them could spark the return game. None did.
This year, the team seems quite serious about addressing their woeful return game. They drafted Ray Fisher from Indiana, whose 36.1 yard kick return average lead the nation in 2009 and set a Big Ten record. They also signed the most feared kick returner in college football last season: Florida's Brandon James. James returned five kicks (four punts, one kick-off) for TDs during his college career. He also averaged 26.1 yards per kick return and 7.4 yards per punt return.
Fisher ran a low 4.3 40 at his Pro Day while James ran a 4.32. Both have tremendous speed and are electric with the football in their hands.
Also in the mix are rookie receiver Blair White and third-year receiver Samuel Giguere.
Adding a potent return game for Peyton Manning and the offense should send chills down the spines of opponents all throughout the NFL.
Stampede Blue prediction: Fisher (kick returner) and James (punt returner)
1 recs |
16 comments
|
Comments
I predict Bullitt plays when we're in Dime
Heck, maybe even Nickel in some situations. Why have a rookie CB come in, when Bullitt’s played so many snaps and is solid in coverage? Anyone remember a certain play when a sure-handed RB didn’t convert a 4-and-2 last season?
Let’s pray Bob plays a lot of games this season and then we can use Bullitt to provide depth at DB.
That really is a great idea
I never really thought about it but the COlts have one of the deepest and talented safety postion in the league and I would love to see a combo of Bullit, Sanders, and Bethea in at the same time.
Will Collie experience the 2nd year bump?
Seems like receivers need two years in the system to become productive—does this mean that Collie be noticably better than last year?
Sadly, "will" was AWOL with the "e"
“will be noticeably…”
I expect more of the same from Collie this season...
I think that the ceiling for a slot receiver is basically Wes Welker in the Pats system – his play from the slot is as good as it gets in the NFL. Collie won’t get to that level in year two, but I do expect more receptions, and maybe he’ll approach 1000 yds, but I doubt that with all the other weapons #18 has to choose from.
The 2010 NFL season will bear witness to a singular, epic moment in history as the world will watch my Colts demoralize and dismantle such the teams which the BRB, BCC and MCM contributors represent, en route to #18's holy ascent into our sport's hallowed history. Here comes the Juggernaut.
by Mr. Indianapolis Colts on Jul 27, 2010 4:41 PM EDT up reply actions
Forgot a few
Left Jaime Thomas out of the o-line discussion. i think he may figure into thier plans. imo thomas and mclendon will be the starting guards. Also Devin Moore. he may have been made obsolete with fisher and james there but i’m interested in seeing what he can do. my prediction for the dimeback…thad turner. he seems like the best fit and plays really similar to marlin jackson. giguere will not make the 53 man roster!…lmao
@ BBS
I’ve noticed every time you mention Lilja getting cut, you say it was for absolutely no reason other than the teams new philosophy of going bigger. But you know that he hurt his knee the week before the superbowl and later failed his physical. You did a write up on the story right after he was released
So why do you act like a baby over Lilja being cut every time you discuss the guard position?
From what you said above
Ryan Lilja is gone; cut seemingly because his 290 pound playing weight was too small for new offensive line coach Pete Metzelaars’ vision moving forward.
Actually from everything I’ve read about his release, Lilja was seemingly let go because the Colts organization didn’t trust his knee for the future after it was re-injured.
And you bring it up again a few lines later
However, if both of those guards do not offer additional size or weight over Ryan Lilja, the question will linger as to why the excellent veteran guard was cut
What gives BBS? You don’t bring up the fact that he failed a physical when you talk about him, even after you wrote about it when the story broke.
Just seems like your taking shots at the new move to get bigger for no reason. The organization knows more than you and if Ryan Lilja was the obvious creme of the crop among Colts guards, he would still be here. Regardless of his size
by Hitstick Killer on Jul 27, 2010 5:50 PM EDT reply actions
Was the Failed Physical ever confirmed?
I don’t know if I take a Twitter message as bible. Plus, he must have been healthy enough for the Chiefs to sign him. I agree that the organization knows more than any of us, and they obviously felt that he wasn’t much better than the guys on the roster given the difference in money.
Failed physical
Hitstick is referring to this: http://www.stampedeblue.com/2010/3/12/1369686/ryan-lilja-failed-a-physical
For me personally, I don’t buy the failed physical excuse. The Chiefs scooped him up within a week of him getting cut. He’s now projected as their starter. He’s worked all through their OTAs, mini-camps, and is ready for their training camp. Lilja is fine. If he weren’t, the Chiefs wouldn’t have signed him to a multi-year contract.
I don’t give the failed physical much weight. Again, that’s just me. Lilja played the entire 2009 season, never missing a snap due to injury. Just one month prior to being cut, he was playing in the Super Bowl. Now, he’s signed to a multi-year deal with KC.
It’s also worth noting that Adam Caplan’s “failed physical” report was never confirmed.
SB Nation's Indianapolis Colts blogger at Stampede Blue. Please make an account so you can post a FanPost, make a FanShot, add some comments, and make some noise. Accounts are free, and only require an email address.
if...
If we’re cutting players because of injuries we’re afraid of, then why not cut Sanders? Cutting Lilja was pretty hasty and seemed to follow on BP’s comments that the Super Bowl was lost because of the OL, not because Garcon didn’t make a catch, or Hank Baskett can’t come up with onside kick, or Reggie Wayne was basically a “no show”, etc. Lilja became the scapegoat for the lost SB.
more on Lilja
M O N E Y just might have played into the decision as it usually does in roster decisions in a sport with a hard cap.
by Lucky Horseshoe on Jul 27, 2010 6:06 PM EDT reply actions
Are you sure?
In any given year with that hard cap, sure. This year, with clearly no cap in sight for the 2010 season, it wouldn’t hurt too much (from a financial perspective) to keep the veteran guard around with all else equal. So… all else is not likely equal; the big question is what it is that isn’t.
If we correlate what LB writes on Polian's views of the SB44 tunring points....
link here with what we are discussing here, then more than likely getting bigger and bulkier in the OL is the reason, more than any failed physical……
If you see my smilieys, think of E.M.H. - our COLTs King of Smileys!
by Manning4ever on Jul 28, 2010 4:25 AM EDT up reply actions

by 















