If you team loses it's QB and goes 1-15. It wasn't a good team to begin with. if the best QB in history can make your 1-15 team go 10-6 and get to the first round of the playoffs. It still doesn't mean it was a good team. It just means you had an exceptional player carry a bad team.
Thinking along these lines will frame many arguments about the actual state of the Colts franchise TODAY.