Why not both? Seriously,the Colts need a quarterback,not to take over and replace Peyton,but to back him up. Look at the mess we are in as a team because there is nobody to play quarterback and give them a chance to win. I know people are bitching about the defense and as far as that goes,I think our defensive strategy needs to change,the Tampa 2 cover defense has been figured out. DUH!!!. But as far as the defense goes,hell if your on the field for 3 1/2 quarters your going to get tired. In Indianapolis #18 is king andshall be till the day he retires (and that's te only way he should never wear a Colts uniform). But,hey let's face the truth we need a quarterback who can play if Peyton cannot. Luck is probably one of the most talanted quarterbacks to be coming out of college in a few years,and that's saying alot,with some of the talent of quarterbacks whom are only in yers 2-4 of their careers. This is obviously just my opinion,but for someone who's been a Colts fan for as long as I have,routing for guys like Mike Pagel and Jack Trudeau and wondered why they (Colts) let Bert Jones (yea,how many of you remember him?) and put up with crybabies like Jeff George and seeing moments of hope wit Jim Harbaugh and FINALLY,the promised land with Manning,I say get Luck now and keep the promise and hope alive for the future cause damnit I don't know if I haveenough life left in me to pass on him (Luck) and wait for another Manning,do you?