Recap Of The Bill Polian Show: Week 1 2011
After Bill Polian's meltdown on the radio following the Colts now-infamous handling of the Week Sixteen game against the New York Jets in 2009, the Colts have blocked the call-in radio program named 'The Bill Polian Show' from Internet listeners. This show features Colts vice chairman Bill Polian, and it allows regular Colts fans to call-in and ask him questions which he, frequently, gets annoyed answering. It is the only Colts content that is not streamed live on the net. Thus, because Colts fans outside the Indianapolis area cannot listen in on the show, we provide highlights from the program, which often include Bill Polian saying things he later claims he did not say. However, since the Colts and Mr. Polian do not provide fans or media with recordings of the show, you'll just have to take our word that what we write below is indeed what Mr. Polian actually said. Hope you enjoy.
Last night was the first episode of the 2011 season's 'The Bill Polian Show,' and for the first time I used Twitter to update people live on what Bill Polian was chatting with Bob Lamey about following the Colts Week 1 embarrassment at the hands of the Texans. The decision to 'live tweet' the show was so well received that the Indianapolis Star, who was unable to get the show's feed on their Internet radio (because it's blocked), followed my updates all night.
In general, the topics of discussion were rather bland, but some interesting nuggets did come out of Polian's mouth, including the announcement that the time is now to search for Peyton Manning's replacement.
Here are the highlights from the show:
- Bill said he heard from Peyton Manning two days ago, and that he is 'fine.' Also said Peyton will be back in weight room 'after some period of time.'
- Bill laughed as he said it seemed he had to turn around every five minutes to stave off rumors regarding Peyton's health. One 'rumor' he specifically addressed was the notion that Peyton did not have a physical around the time he signed his contract. Polian said Peyton did have a physical before signing his contract, contradicting a report from PFT saying he did not. I've contacted Mike Florio and he said the report is fact, not rumor. So, either Bill lied on the radio last night, or Florio's source is incorrect.
- Polian reiterated that there is no timeframe of Peyton's recovery. Colts plan to keep Peyton on the active roster as long as possible. Bill compared the Colts saving a roster spot for Manning similar to them saving spot for Bob Sanders last year. Peyton will not be allowed to practice until doctors give the OK.
- Regarding Sunday's loss, Polian said 'similar defensive situation as last year.' Colts could not stop run. Game was 'ugly.' Lots of 'little things' went wrong, such as penalties and busted assignments on the offensive line.
- Polian said Colts mistakes 'correctable.' Team must adjust tactically and schematically to Kerry Collins at QB over 18.
- Said the Colts 'not consistent mentally or physically.'
- When asked by a caller why the Colts cut Dan Orlovsky and kept Curtis Painter, Polian said he felt Painter played better in preseason than Dan Orlovsky. Polian cited Packers preseason game.
- Polian said Kerry Collins throws harder ball than Peyton Manning. Also, during the game, the sack-fumble on Collins was a missed blocking assignment.
- Lamey and Polian both highlighted that Collins' QB rating Sunday was better than Schaub's.
- Polian on Collins: Tough player. 'Cool customer' in the pocket. Courageous. Collins has become much more of a complete QB since when Polian drafted him in 1995. Arm still as strong.
- When asked by a caller about whether the Colts will address QB situation in the 2012 NFL Draft, Polian said he's out scouting all kinds of players every week. Said he spoke with Peyton when drafting the last contract and discussed the option of the team drafting a replacement. Polian liked several QBs in the 2011 Draft. None fell to Colts.
- According to Polian, Peyton recognizes his career is in 'home stretch.' However, Peyton will come back and play. Colts expect Peyton next year. However, the time has come to give 'serious consideration' to QB position.
- When asked about run defense, Polian said Colts must do better job stopping kind of running Houston does, aka cut blocking. The idea that 'anybody' can run on us is not factual, however, 'The idea that Houston can run on us is fact.'
- Polian said Anthony Castonzo had a fine game. Jeff Linkenbach did as well. Colts running game looked good yesterday. He cited the team rushing average of 4.0 yards a carry. 'Running game improved.'
- Polian addressed the 'sound byte' that the Colts are looking to get 'bigger' on the oline. Colts not trying to get bigger on oline. 'Trying to get better.' Polian said former-Colts and current Eagle o-line coach Howard Mudd would have liked Castonzo and Ben Ijalana. Colts do not want 335 pound olinemen like the 49ers.
- When asked about why the team deactivated Jerry Hughes on Sunday, Polian said Hughes had 'a reasonably good preseason.' Said Hughes is principally a pass rusher, and Colts wanted to use more run-stuffing DEs on Sunday. Thus, Hughes deactivated.
If you listened to the show and noticed anything we missed, please add it in the comments below.
45 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
We can all agree,
that Florio lies, hates the organization, Polian, Manning and has no source inside the Colts.
by Ty46 on Sep 13, 2011 11:13 AM EDT reply actions 1 recs
Disagree
I’ve spoke to Mike many times regarding this. He does not hate the Colts or Manning, but he pretty clearly dislikes Polian. And, like it or not, Florio’s sources are usually right. I’ve never known him to lie.
SB Nation's Indianapolis Colts blogger at Stampede Blue and editor of SB Nation Indiana.
He regularly finds a way to take shots at Manning even when writing articles about other teams.
He can claim he has a “fact”, when his source could be a homeless guy on the street. There is no person inside the Colts organization, that would tell inside info to Florio.
'There is no person inside the Colts organization, that would tell inside info to Florio.'
Not true. People inside the Colts org talk to Florio all the time. Hell, I have sources inside Colts org.
SB Nation's Indianapolis Colts blogger at Stampede Blue and editor of SB Nation Indiana.
Your one rumor from a source was never confirmed
Colts org talking to media is not the same as spilling secrets.
BBS, just curious
I know it is very competitive with guys (and who they work for) to get the first inside scoops.
Who do you think is the most connected with GM etc. for information-Peter King, De Florio,La Canfora? I definitely think Jay Glaser is the most connected to players for inside scoops.
"Peyton Manning came to LA and didn't even call me"
Anybody else get the feeling...
That Manning is absolutely done for the season? With Polian’s comments, and Irsay’s tweets – the team seems centered around a 2012 Manning return.
There’s nothing wrong with that stance – but if that’s the case, why isn’t he on IR yet?
www.Coltsider.com
check out the new Colts blog!
Team has a chance to go 5-5 or even 6-4 before the BYE
But playoffs is unlikely. Team desperately needs high draft to have a chance in 2012-14.
i have a chance to hit the lotto too....
by BLOODontheTRACKS on Sep 13, 2011 12:11 PM EDT up reply actions
I can't disagree with the possibilites of beating these teams
but I am sure they are saying the same thing about the Manningless Colts right now.
"Peyton Manning came to LA and didn't even call me"
if the team does that and Peyton comes back
they have a chance and Houston looked great 1st game last yr eevryone said they were winning teh division and look what happened!!!
by OBGYNOSUPREME on Sep 13, 2011 12:17 PM EDT up reply actions
They need to sell $9 hotdogs and $20 beers at Lucas Oil
If they put Manning on IR people will stop coming to the games. Nobody in the Colts org wants a half-empty stadium.
He thinks so much of QB Curtis Painter........
….that he called him Matt Painter on two occasions during the show…….on the last one he acknowledged calling him Matt.
So that got me thinking…..maybe Matt Painter could actually play QB for us and replace Curtis Painter.
What do you guys think?
Not a good sign...
…when the boss keeps calling you someone else’s name after years of employment.
“Smithers, who is that man?”
Loved the tweets all during the show last night
Thanks BBS, us out of market Colts fans appreciate it!!!
Question for BBS
Living in LA, I obviously get most of my Colts info from internet, NFL Network, and watching Colts on Direct TV. I think it is strange that many people cannot listen to Polian’s show. Are they doing it from Bob Lamey’s hot tub? I did listened to Lameys’ postgame show on WFNI (via internet). Just seems weird,I can listen to many competitive podcasts and not listen to Polian. Why is it blocked?
"Peyton Manning came to LA and didn't even call me"
Why it is blocked
We did some digging into this last year and got some answers, many of which were done ‘off the record’ by people who no longer work at the radio station that carries The Bill Polian Show.
Basically, I am the reason the show is blocked. Me. BBS.
It all stemmed from Polian’s blow-up at fans two years ago, when he insulted and demeaned the concerns and frustrations of fans who called in and voiced extreme disapproval over how management and the coaches handled the benching of players in the Week Sixteen game against the Jets. One caller, a woman, brought up the point that it was unfair to charge fans high ticket prices during a recession only to see the team pull starters. This caller really seemed to get under Polian’s skin. He accused her on air of reading from “talking points,” and did not allow her to respond to his accusation. Here’s a write-up I did of the show moments after it finished:
The final caller, who was cut off when the show was seemingly stopped short ten minutes early, was the one who sounded as if he got the under Polian’s skin the most. He stated pretty much what many of us have said the last 24 hours. Polian made a claim that the Colts give maximum effort during every game, and expect that same effort from players, coaches, and personnel people. The caller countered with an obvious, and devastating retort: Benching starters at a critical time in a ball game is NOT giving maximum effort to win.
This seemed to drive Polian nuts.
Polian then countered, with his voice much more animated, by asking the caller what would do if he ran the Indianapolis Colts with the upcoming game against the Buffalo Bills. Would he force injured players to play in a meaningless game? The caller countered that such a request or situation was not what he and other fans were questioning. The caller then seemed to make the point that Peyton Manning, Dallas Clark, and Reggie Wayne were all pulled from the football game yesterday at a critical time, and the benchings were not injury-related. The issue wasn’t playing injured players. The issue was benching healthy ones when the game was still winnable.
It was at this point that the broadcast went dead.When the show went ‘dead,’ it cut from the caller talking directly to random music and, later, commercial filler. At the time, it seemed as if Polian had walked off the set of the radio show. That’s what I thought, and that’s what everyone else thought when they listened to it. I write what I thought. PFT picked it up. It made national news. It REALLY pissed off Bill Polian.
The next day, the Colts called the radio station and told them to pull the Internet feed for the show.
Now, to this day, I’m still convinced Polian walked off the show. The radio station covered for him and provided some lame excuse about needing to air ten minutes worth of commercials. But, I never really bought that excuse. That’s just me.
Since then, I’ve been toxic waste to the Colts. It certainly is not fun when the team you love treats you like garbage, but that’s how the Polian-led Colts operate. Bill Polian is a very divisive figure with Colts fans, and I don’t think many will shed a tear when he retires. He’s a brilliant talent evaluator (for the most part), but he is a truly odious assclown when it comes to the treatment of fans. If he’d have been anyone else, that radio blow-up would have gotten him fired or fined by the team.
In many ways, the Colts are STILL paying for that dust-up.
So, yeah. I’m the reason the show is blocked. Sorry. The Colts would prefer to lay the blame on me so fans will get mad at me, which is totally insane. But, hey, that’s Bill Polian.
SB Nation's Indianapolis Colts blogger at Stampede Blue and editor of SB Nation Indiana.
Thanks. I missed all this drama as I joined this site after all this.
"Peyton Manning came to LA and didn't even call me"
There is no good reason
for Polian to be so fan unfriendly
by OBGYNOSUPREME on Sep 13, 2011 12:13 PM EDT up reply actions
brilliant talent evaluator (for the most part)?
Well, he chose Manning. But, I’m not sure that was brilliant. Anyone would have, I believe, after exercising due diligence. And, there are a handful of really good players on the team, but brilliant? Can’t agree with that one, especially after seeing some of the more ‘recent’ decisions.
At one time maybe he was
That time, if it ever existed for the Colts, is long gone.
In my opinion,
the only real brilliance with this team is Peyton Manning. Reggie Wayne is a great receiver. However, if Polian happened to draft a different wide receiver instead of Wayne that year, I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if that receiver became a star as well. We would just get used to different names in the skill positions. That’s one example. I believe you could apply it to everyone on the team. The only indispensable player is Manning.
A few other good picks by Polian
I don’t like defending him but my disgust for him is not blind hatred. He’s made some good choices in the past.
Taking Freeney so high turned out well.
Mathis as a 5th rounder was a good find. Same with Bethea as a 6th.
Taking Edge over Williams was a great move, one that a lot of people disagreed with.
I do agree guys like Reggie and Dallas are more products of Manning than simply incredible talents on their own. They obviously are good players but we’ve seen before when you plug in a Tamme or a Utecht into the same role you get similar production. It took Reggie 3 years to really get it in the Colts offense, I’d imagine Chad Johnson, Steve Smith, or TJ Housh would’ve all done as well or even better, and all were drafted after Wayne the same year.
Really?
You’re serious?
SB Nation's Indianapolis Colts blogger at Stampede Blue and editor of SB Nation Indiana.
Of course not
I’m not a simpleton. But if it would get them to resume streaming……
by MadStork on Sep 13, 2011 9:06 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Why is it still the Bill Polian show?
I thought Chris was taking over? Why is Bill so suddenly and obviously back in the driver’s seat of this team?
Bill is looking really old these days
I wonder how his health is. Every picture of him makes him look like he’s aged by 10 more years. Maybe they had to transition to Chris earlier than they wanted.
Why didn't Indy Star just listen on the radio?
So be pretty easy since, ya know, they are based in Indianapolis….
AM-FM
Not many people have AM-FM radios anymore.
SB Nation's Indianapolis Colts blogger at Stampede Blue and editor of SB Nation Indiana.
Maybe we cannot listen to the live stream but it might be worth posting the show somewhere on the webs for the out of towners. Look here:
http://www.jakeludington.com/ask_jake/20051101_pc_recording_of_am_and_fm_radio.html
Seems pretty easy.
Also I wonder how this service works? http://tunein.com/radio/Indianapolis-r100041/
I am guessing that the feed goes off the air when polian goes on it.
"If an expert says it can't be done, get another expert"
- DBG
People at IndyStar dont have AM-FM radios? Thats a joke right? Go out to your freakign car then!
LMAO at that statement
Go Blue!
Revenue - Expenses = Profit
by dezznutz1001 on Sep 13, 2011 1:31 PM EDT up reply actions
Polian's reasoning for Hughes to be inactive is BS
why a guy his size who supposedly has good speed can’t help our special teams is a ringing indictment for what a bust Huges is as a first round draft pick
Safford would have been better
we could have had him and Castanzo
by OBGYNOSUPREME on Sep 13, 2011 1:21 PM EDT up reply actions
Hindsight is 20-20
It was weird to hear that story by Bill Parcels on ESPN the other day concerning Cameron Wake…if Polian could have convinced him to sign here there woull be no Jerry hughes right now
Go Blue!
Revenue - Expenses = Profit
by dezznutz1001 on Sep 13, 2011 1:34 PM EDT up reply actions
hindsight is 20-20
but he is making the big bucks to make the correct decision, I get paid bucks to do the right thing in medicine, he deserves criticism if he messes up, if I do something below the standard of care I can be sued , so I have no sympathy for him when he messes up, it would be a shame if he doesn’t get Peyton the proper talent to get back in the SB at least 1-2 more times before he retires
by OBGYNOSUPREME on Sep 13, 2011 1:50 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
hindsight is 20-20
but he is making the big bucks to make the correct decision, I get paid bucks to do the right thing in medicine, he deserves criticism if he messes up, if I do something below the standard of care I can be sued , so I have no sympathy for him when he messes up, it would be a shame if he doesn’t get Peyton the proper talent to get back in the SB at least 1-2 more times before he retires
by OBGYNOSUPREME on Sep 13, 2011 1:50 PM EDT up reply actions
pittiful
polian has spent a decade trying to disprove the likes of florio and anyone who challenges his nepotic and autocratic regime. in the end he ruins a special talent in manning and brings down a team like he did at buffalo and carolina

by 

































