Indianapolis Colts 2012 NFL Draft Mock W/ TRADE SCENARIO
This is a mock draft for the Indianapolis Colts based on team needs and players that are quite capable of feeling in holes and adding much needed depth. This mock is not to be taking seriously as it is just based on speculation and writing with the limited knowledge of the 2012 Draft Class.
The difference between this mock and the last one is that the 1st Overall selection is being mocked as traded away to the Cleveland Browns for two 1st Round picks (4th and 22nd overall), a 3rd Round (68th overall), and a 4th Round (118th overall) in the 2012 NFL Draft.
1st Round: (from Cleveland Browns)
Robert Griffin III, QB
6-2 220
Baylor
Griffin isn't as highly praised as fellow QB prospect Andrew Luck, but the 2011 Heisman Trophy winner has just as many tangibles as Luck himself. RG3 is quite known to be able to make plays with his feet as well as his arm. He has great speed for a NFL QB despite being undersized for the position and puts great touch and velocity on his passes. RG3 has stated that he wants to play for the Colts over any of the other 31 NFL teams.
RG3 would make a great protege' under Peyton Manning's mentoring. He's seen as a "pass first-run second" type QB when he drops back in the pocket, has great accuracy when throwing on the run and has been considered to have the strongest arm in this year's draft. Weather he gets selected by the Colts or someone else; they will have a great playmaker on their team.
1st Round: (from Cleveland Browns)
Alfonzo Dennard, CB
5-10 205
University of Nebraska
With this selection, the Colts can finally have a solid CB tandem and legit #2 corner in Dennard. The secondary has been one of the weakest elements in the Colts defense these past few seasons.
Dennard is a very impressive CB despite being shorter than most NFL WRs, his lack of height has not hindered him in his playing ability. Dennard has shut down or limited TOP WR draft prospects for the last two years including BJ Cunningham, Justin Blackmon, Alshon Jeffery, and Marvin McNutt. His ability to jam receivers at the line of scrimmage, play aggressive man coverage, and bump-and- run press coverage in a zone-based scheme will make Dennard a key asset in terms of rebuilding a defensive secondary.
2nd Round:
Mark Barron, SS
6-2 215
University of Alabama
Melvin Bullitt has been on IR for the past two seasons, for this reason; the Colts have failed to field a solid Strong Safety who can compliment FS Antoine Bethea. In a weak Safety class, Barron is the top dog this year at his position.
Mark Barron has that "perfect" Strong Safety build, he is quite solid in keeping Tight Ends in check and can deliver a punishing hit to a WR roaming into his zone. Barron supports the run very well and has great awareness and instincts in the deep half of the field. Mark Barron was one of the key instrumental players in Alabama's #1 ranked defense and BCS National Championship.
3rd Round:
Michael Brewster, Center
6-4 310
Ohio State University
Jeff Saturday has been the Colts stalwart Center since 1999, but he isn't getting any younger and has also considered retirement. Saturday will be 37 by the time the 2012 NFL regular season kicks off. It is quite unknown what he plans to do and if he still has something left in the tank.
Brewster is one of the TOP 5 Centers in this year's draft, he is very strong and athletic for a guy his size. Brewster's biggest attribute would be his pass protection, but hopefully scouts will not sleep on his run blocking abilities. Michael Brewster will fit perfectly in the zone-blocking scheme of the Indianapolis Colts. Brewster has been a starter at OSU for all 4-seasons since his commitment in 2008.
3rd Round: (from Cleveland Browns)
Josh Chapman, NT/DT
6-1 310
University of Alabama
Besides the feeble secondary of the Colts, the interior of the D-Line hasn't been solid in terms of stopping the run. Unless the Colts improve in this area, they are more susceptible to lose games in this fashion.
Rumor has it that the Indianapolis Colts would be switching to 3-4 or even implying a hybrid 3-4/4-3 defense. Chapman has the strength, size, and toughness to play NT, 1-tech DT, or 3-4 DE. Like fellow draft prospects Mark Barron, Robert Lester, Courtney Upshaw, and Dre’ Kirkpatrick; Chapman was one of the players fielded in 2011 to create one of the best top ranked defenses in the entire nation.
4th Round:
Jordan White, WR
6-0 215
Western Michigan University
The Colts have 3 main WRs as Free Agents this off-season. Reggie Wayne is a 33-year-old veteran who would most likely demand more money to stay on the team; Anthony Gonzales was only productive for 2 years before being labeled "injury prone" and hasn't started a game since 2009. Pierre Garcon, who was the most productive Colts WR in 2011, has great speed to burn the defense and is unrivaled when it comes to athleticism. A few teams in need of a #2 WR would shell out big bucks to get Garcon out of a Colts uniform.
WMU's Jordan White was one of the nation's most productive WRs last season with 140 receptions, 1,911 receiving yards with 17 total TDs and has increased his draft stock with decent route running skills, great separation and open field speed; leaving defenders in the dust. Manning and/or RG3 should be able to turn White into a formidable possession WR.
4th Round: (from Cleveland)
Jayron Hosley, CB/PR/KR
5-10 173
Virginia Tech
The Colts secondary needs more than just a number #2 CB, they can use another solid nickleback/dimeback. Jacob Lacey has proven that he isn't a solid corner despite being quite a solid tackler. Kevin Thomas, while solid in coverage, lacks the aggressiveness and physicality to play in a Cover-2 or man-coverage scheme.
The biggest knack on Hosley is his size, which will cause him to slip within the draft ranks. Despite being undersized, he is quite a sound tackler and can diagnose and jump routes with his speed and quickness. Hosley is one of the more dominate ball-hawks in this year's draft, and 2010 he led the nation in INTs with 9, he is proven to be a decent zone guy who has tremendous instincts and can track the ball down in deep coverage. While being small, Jayron Hosley can become of the "biggest" draft steals in current years.
4th Round: (Compensatory)
Lonnie Edwards, OG
6-4 322
Texas Tech University
The Indianapolis Colts should make it a primary objective to solidify the Offensive Line, specifically the interior. For years since the releases of All-Pro guards Jake Scott and Ryan Lilja, the Colts hasn't had a solid running game. Without any breakthrough in the run game, the Colts Offense will always be tuned to become one-dimensional.
Edwards has had a solid senior year and in turn; improved his draft stock. His physicality at the line of scrimmage in the run game will have a major impact for RBs on the Colts roster. Pass blocking isn't even an issue, as Lonnie Edwards would benefit in a power blocking or zone-blocking scheme.
5th Round:
Mychal Kendricks, OLB
6-0 240
University of California (Berkely)
A 3-4/4-3 hybrid defense isn't a bad idea as long as you have the players who can be versatile or have the players who can play either one. OLB hasn't been much of a solid position in terms of good coverage for the Colts since Cato June, Freddie Keiaho, and Clint Session all have been released and signed by other teams.
Kendricks have a unique skillset of having the ability to play decent man coverage on TEs, dropping back in coverage in a zone scheme, and supporting the run. He has good awareness in terms of finding the ball carrier or reading a QB's eyes, Kendricks had a solid senior year and was voted as the Pac-12 Defensive Player of the Year. Keep in mind that cause of an injury to his shoulder, his stock in this year's draft has tumbled significantly.
6th Round:
Jerrell Young, FS/SS
6-1 205
University of South Florida
Antoine Bethea is one of the most underrated and promising Safeties in the NFL today. Despite playing in a horrible to mediocre secondary, he has been the face of the Colts secondary and has been solid since 2006. Besides Bethea; the Colts have no suitable depth at FS behind Bethea, who has a great bill of health by missing only 4 games in his 6-year tenure as a Colt.
Young is known for his solid tackling form, punishing hits, and makes QBs think twice of sending a WR on certain routes due to his presence alone. Very versatile in the backfield, he can play both Free and Strong Safeties depending on scheme and is very instinctive in pass coverage with decent run stopping capabilities.
6th Round: (Compensatory)
Antoine McClain, OG
6-6 330
Clemson University
One of the main reasons why the Colts have had trouble establishing a true running threat is cause of poor interior play. Jamey Richard and Ryan Diem both have proven that they're not qualified to have the starting job at RG. The guard position is one of areas that need more solidification and improvement on the O-Line.
The reason why C.J. Spiller was a top RB prospect was cause of this big fellow, at 6-6 330; McClain has been extremely solid in run blocking and has propelled Clemson's rushing attack over the years. His pass blocking skills would come to question as he reaches the NFL level.
7th Round:
Rishard Matthews, WR/PR
6-2 215
University Of Nevada (Reno)
Pierre Garcon, Anthony Gonzales, and Reggie Wayne are all 2012 Free Agents. Unless the Colts resign 2 or all 3 of the listed WRs, they will need help finding fresh young starters or much needed depth.
Rishard Matthews was one of Colin Kaepernick's primary targets due to his elusive quickness and relative good size. When he isn't in the lineup at WR, he can be an asset on special teams as a punt returner. Matthews utilizes his size and athleticism well against defenders in the open field and can cause trouble for opposing defenses trying to bring him down after a catch. Teams looking for a decent possession WR would have to give Matthews a good look for his qualities.
This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of Stampede Blue's writers or editors. It does reflect the views of this particular fan though, which is as important as the views of Stampede Blue's writers or editors.
38 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
horrible mock
i suggest not even reading it.
why???
Just because he/she didn’t mock Luck doesn’t make it horrible. You need to get off Andrew Luck’s dick before you get pregnant
Colts fan since Tony Dungy's 48th Birthday.
Free will is an illusion, but pragmatically, the illusion of self (ego), choice, freedom, consciousness, are all necessary for the game or struggle to move. No struggle, no universe.
Get well soon, Peyton Manning
by ColtsFan504 on Feb 11, 2012 12:31 PM EST up reply actions
why?
because we are taking luck
so its a waste of time to do anything other than take luck with the first pick
OK
but you think this was a horrible mock cause he didn’t have Luck. You so worried about Luck, you didn’t even check out the other players he mocked at other positions.
I think this would be the best scenario as for as trading the 1st Overall pick. We can still get a QB and fill other needs with additional picks, but I guess you not trying to see beyond that. Just Luck this and Luck that.
Well fuck Luck, and I hope hes becomes a bust regardless of what team selects him. Everybody all on his dick like he’s the best QB in human history
Colts fan since Tony Dungy's 48th Birthday.
Free will is an illusion, but pragmatically, the illusion of self (ego), choice, freedom, consciousness, are all necessary for the game or struggle to move. No struggle, no universe.
Get well soon, Peyton Manning
The colts cant be fixed in one draft.
And trading the first pick doesn’t solve all of the problems. Im sure the colts grade Luck higher than Griffin, and they will select him first for that reason. Simple as that.
Further trading to the four spot doesn’t guarantee a shot at Griffin. Its widely believed he’ll be drafted second or third.
The original post likely assumes the colts pick up the $28 million bonus, which also thwarts a rebuilding process.
If they decide to pay Manning all that money, they might as well just tool up the roster and grab a back-up qb in a later round.
by mlc2656 on Feb 11, 2012 1:57 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
omahacolt = definition of a fanboy.
coltsfan504 no need to try to explain yourself to omahacolt since his bromance has reached weird brokeback mountain levels. surprised the kid has not started a iheartluck.com site.
by BigMan74 on Feb 11, 2012 1:40 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
what dont you understand
about my thoughts on luck?
1) we need a qb
2) he is the best qb in the draft.
how are you not capable of understanding this logical thought process?
Leaf was the best QB in 1998
and look how well that turned out. Luck might be the “best” in this year’s draft, doesn’t mean he will turn out to be the best. Michael Vick got outplayed by a 2nd Rounder (Brees) despite the fact he was a first overall selection.
Everything that glitters ain’t gold
Colts fan since Tony Dungy's 48th Birthday.
Free will is an illusion, but pragmatically, the illusion of self (ego), choice, freedom, consciousness, are all necessary for the game or struggle to move. No struggle, no universe.
Get well soon, Peyton Manning
To be fair though, Luck is more like Manning than Leaf. Leaf had “upside” and declared after one big year. Manning had more consistent production over several years as a starter and an undeserved reputation for being unable to win the big game.
Luck is a four year starter with consistent production who has lead his team to big wins. Is he as good as the hype? That remains to be seen. BUT he is the best prospect in this years class and is certainly better than any of the quarterbacks from last year.
I'm not the type to buy the "best prospect" thing
I have seen the “best” get outplayed year in and year out. History has a habit of repeating itself, I really don’t have anything against Luck, I just hate that everyone here is trying to push Manning out the door for some college prospect.
I’ll take a 36 year old QB with three neck surgeries who has won a SB and is a future HOF over a college prospect any day.
Colts fan since Tony Dungy's 48th Birthday.
Free will is an illusion, but pragmatically, the illusion of self (ego), choice, freedom, consciousness, are all necessary for the game or struggle to move. No struggle, no universe.
Get well soon, Peyton Manning
For a season or two..
I would take Manning over anyone, let a lone a college prospect. However, if you’re looking to set your franchise up for the next decade? Not so smart.
by Adam McDougal on Feb 11, 2012 2:49 PM EST up reply actions
so what
you found an example of the #1 pick not being the best. holy shit. good for you. that has nothing to do with drafting luck.
It has a lot to do with drafting Luck
It would hurt your poor little heart if Luck was to get outplayed by a QB that was drafted in the 2nd round or later
Just because he’s the “best” prospect doesn’t means he’s the best pick at QB for the Colts or any other team.
Colts fan since Tony Dungy's 48th Birthday.
Free will is an illusion, but pragmatically, the illusion of self (ego), choice, freedom, consciousness, are all necessary for the game or struggle to move. No struggle, no universe.
Get well soon, Peyton Manning
I agree
It’s unfair that Andrew Luck has gotten so much hype because there are so many people that will naturally disregard anything or anyone that is billed as the next big thing. Is the media always right? Of course not. But there is a reason these sports guys get paid to give their opinion and the people on this board are not. Generally, they know more and are more qualified to judge these things. With that being said, there is always a possibility of them being wrong and Luck being a bust, but to think that RG3 is more of a certainty than Luck is absurd. Yeah, he’ll be an exciting player to watch, but he is a risk. Everyone brings up Ryan Leaf when it comes to Luck, but there are far more fitting bust examples for a guy like Griffin. As a fan of a team that has gone from such amazing highs to a depressing low, I wouldn’t want to gamble with any position at this point, let alone the most important one.
by Adam McDougal on Feb 11, 2012 2:47 PM EST up reply actions
I think a fairer example for Luck from recent years would be Matt Ryan or Joe Flacco. The risk isn’t that Luck will bust because he probably won’t. The risk is he’ll be a good-not-great franchise QB
by TrueBlue87 on Feb 11, 2012 3:39 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
This might be perhaps one of the best Colts mock ever
I think we should take David DeCastro with the 22nd Overall pick instead of Alfonzo Dennard. Dennard might fall into the second round or we can find another CB in the 3rd Round.
I think Jayron Hosely will be a beast if he can just add more weight. At 173, he will get abused by larger WRs, but he definitely will be ball hawking like Ed Reed but only in the CB position.
We should get more picks from the Browns than just an additional 1st Round, a 3rd and 4th round. If they wanted to trade they might just give us both of their 4th Rounders and a 6th Rounder.
Overall, I give this mock an A- cause you selected players by what we need instead of that BPA nonsense.
Colts fan since Tony Dungy's 48th Birthday.
Free will is an illusion, but pragmatically, the illusion of self (ego), choice, freedom, consciousness, are all necessary for the game or struggle to move. No struggle, no universe.
Get well soon, Peyton Manning
The best way to draft is actually on a need/value axis. For example, if the Colts are sitting at 34 and Minnifield and Sanu are both available, you have to look at who is the better value because both fill a need.
CB is more of a need than WR this year
But I see where you are going with this. Manning can turn any WR into a serviceable weapon considering the receiver’s own talent and skill-set. I think getting a CB and SS in the first 4 rounds would do us better justice.
Colts fan since Tony Dungy's 48th Birthday.
Free will is an illusion, but pragmatically, the illusion of self (ego), choice, freedom, consciousness, are all necessary for the game or struggle to move. No struggle, no universe.
Get well soon, Peyton Manning
Well, I would say both corner and wide receiver are huge needs. After all, we could potentially lose three of our five wide outs to free agency.
You’re also assuming Manning will be back next year. I think we have to operate under the assumption that he won’t.
Also, there really aren’t any standout strong safety prospects. Barron is ok, but he’s struggled in man coverage throughout his career
Did you all miss the 2011 season?
“Needs” are out the door this year, guys. The Colts will be in pure best player available mode for the next few years. Almost every position other than QB will be a “need.”
Our “needs” going into 2012 will include replacements for Mathis, Wayne, Bracket, and Bullet. It may also include Clark, Freeney and /or Saturday. I don’t expect the Colts’ new managers to do housecleaning but high priced FA veterans are a no-brainer and the trade value of Clark and Freeney may be too tempting.
Any player not in the team’s 2014 plans is on the bubble.
I would go Barron with the second pick
He is the only safety who might be able to start in year one. With such little depth, someone else would grab him before the second round. There are about 8-10 CBs who would be a huge addition to our secondary. Grab the best one available in the second round.
by PeytonTheManning on Feb 13, 2012 6:01 PM EST up reply actions
I think its stupid that there are so many vocal fans who think we should take RG3 over Luck because Luck’s gonna be a bust and other random shit.
Of course RG3 wants to be a Colt over any other team… cuz that’d mean he’s the number 1 pick. That means more money and fame for him… thats all he cares about. If you look at the dude’s comments, he’s a cocky prick. You don’t show you’re humble by saying how humble you are – thats hypocritical.
Having said that, I think he will do good things in the NFL. He’s very talented. But you know what? So’s Cam, and Mike Vick, and Donovon McNabb…
We don’t need talent. We need a guy who has proven himself with consistency. I don’t know if any of you guys have seen Luck play, but I’m from Pac 12 land, and saw him a lot. The guy is perfect in the redzone. He’s maintained brilliant stats over 2 seasons… called him own plays at the line, and made his mediocre teammates look amazing. He makes great decisions… he knows when to handoff (in one game he handed off 40 times in a blowout win), versus when to throw. The guy’s bottom line is winning… not padding his stats which all the other glory boy college qb’s do (like RG3).
Not to mention, he’s also brilliant at short zone throws. In the NFL, thats where the passing game succeeds. All top teams limit big plays… you gotta beat them slowly and methodically. That’s why Luck is the obvious pick – no one comes close to excelling at those throws.
People compare Luck to Leaf… thats flat out stupid. The only similarity is that they’re last name begins with L and is 4 letters long.
Luck is not going to be a bust. If you’ve seen him play, you’d know that. Busts happen when you take potential over proven skill… thats not the case here.
So ya this mock draft is stupid. Even if we get an extra pick… QB’s win super bowls. We can fit the other pieces in later. The Colts would be very very stupid to pass on Luck.
Ok Pac 12 guy.
Have you ever seen RG3 play on a regular bases? Why is he a cocky prick? Because he has confidence. If all he cared about was fame. He would have played for Texas, probably won 2 or 3 Hiesmans and most likely won a National championship. Instead he went along with his coach(called loyalty to the person who recruited him) to Baylor. Knowing full well he would NOT get the attention like he would, having gone to Texas. He would have to earn his prase(which he did) at Baylor, along with a Top level education. It would be interesting to see how each player would have performed by switching there circumstances. RG3 to Stanford and Luck to Baylor. I know my choice. As far as money. Sure who wouldn’t want more. I don’t hear Luck offering to play for free anywhere.
Ya know what?
Luck could be a bust. RG3 could be a bust. We don’t know. What we are all almost certain of, whether we like it or not, is that the Colts are going to draft Luck. As Colts fans, how about we all just support him. He’s most likely our starting qb in 2012. There’s no point in shitting on our future franchise qb ( even if you don’t think he deserves to be). Just accept it and rally behind your favorite team.
If they draft him, I'll support him
Until that happens, there’s no reason to just accept it as inevitable. Have you not noticed how crazy Irsay is? He could decide to trade down three times, cut Manning, and sign Matt Flynn. He says one thing and changes his mind two weeks later. I will be waiting to see what happens in March and at the draft. It’s absurd to claim you know what that guy is going to do. He doesn’t know, because he has way too long to change his mind…again.
by PeytonTheManning on Feb 13, 2012 6:06 PM EST up reply actions
Notice
I said “what we are ALMOST certain of”. No one knows anything really until it happens, but it’s not like Irsay has been hush hush about his draft day plans. There have been enough indications Luck will be drafted by the Colts that one would have to be at least 90% sure it’ll happen. And, despite Irsay’s “craziness”, what actually is absurd is the notion that the Colts won’t draft one of Luck or Griffin. I mean, really?
by Adam McDougal on Feb 13, 2012 7:12 PM EST up reply actions
sure
And the one thing I would do if I had the most valuable first pick ever is to make other teams realize they are going to have to drastically overpay to get it. I would make sure everybody knew that I already knew what my plans were, and they didn’t involve trading the pick.
I definitely never said to skip on Luck and RGIII. My preference is to trade down to 4 or 6 for 3 first picks and as many other picks as possible. Then, trade a couple picks to go back to number 2 for RGIII.
Franchise QB who can sit, and a handful of extra high
draft picks for reloading.
If St. Louis wants too much for the number two pick, then use one or two of the 10-12 first and second round picks the team would have in the next three years. Develop him, and let him take the reins after Peyton. That would give the new coach a chance to build the defense in his way, and his staff can develop their QB of the future. Bruce Arians has proven his ability in the past when it comes to QBs.
by PeytonTheManning on Feb 13, 2012 7:46 PM EST up reply actions
Use one or two
To draft a QB or two. That is what I meant. Skipped a word there.
by PeytonTheManning on Feb 13, 2012 7:48 PM EST up reply actions
Mock Draft
1 Andrew Luck QB Stanford
2 Brandon Thompson DT Clemson
3 Dwayne Allen TE Clemson
4 Jamell Fleming CB Oklahoma
4 Ryan Broyles WR Oklahoma
5 George Iloka SS Boise State
6 Danny Trevathan LB Kentucky
7 Derek Dennis OG Temple
7 Justin Francis DE Rutgers
Dwayne Allen
Will be a late-1st round pick.
www.Coltsider.com
check out the new Colts blog!
Two big problems
The second biggest flaw with this mock is that there is no way RG3 is available at Cleveland’s pick. He goes at 2 or worst at 3. QBs are so critical that someone will offer the talent challenged Rams too many good picks to pass up.
The biggest problem is it does not have any Luck in it. He may be a flop in the NFL but he is generally rated as a once a decade prospect… and at the QB spot to boot. If the Colts do trade the top pick, they better be getting a lot more than what this mock reflects.
The last time the Colts traded a once-a-decade QB prospect we got a few decent players, no difference makers, while Denver got two Super Bowl wins.
Didn't it also take denver like 15 years
To win those super bowls?
i don't give autographs
by muncie_in_this on Feb 12, 2012 11:25 AM EST via Android app up reply actions
they went to 3 others before they won
if you have a point, its not a good one
I don't like this at all.
First off, IF the Colts trade the #1 overall pick, they better get more than (2) 1st-rounders, a 3rd rounder, and 4th rounder.
Secondly, if we are going to take our “QB of the future” – why would you take the 2nd best QB at 4 instead of taking the best QB prospect (in 30 years) at 1.
Thirdly, Mark Barron won’t be available in the 2nd round. He’s a middle-to-late 1st rounder.
Also, IMO, secondary isn’t a dire need in the draft. Why? A couple reasons:
-Our coaching staff has experience developing secondary talent. We have a lot of young players in the secondary (Lefeged, Bullitt, Powers, Lacey, Rucker, Thomas). Not saying they are going to transform into Pro-Bowlers overnight, but I’d like to think that in a better system (instead of the Tampa-2) and some better coaching, our current group will be much improved.
-The secondary can always be addressed in Free Agency. It always seems that there are a handful of starting-caliber CB’s and Safeties on the open market every off-season…Look at what Houston did with their secondary last year.
-We have a more immediate need at NT (and D-line in general). Even if we don’t transform into a 3-4 defense overnight, we can’t run a single snap of it in 2012 without a true NT. You can get by with a suspect secondary (see: New England, New Orleans, Green Bay, Baltimore even) – you cannot get by with sub-par front-7 play (look how far that took the Giants, 49ers, Patriots).
www.Coltsider.com
check out the new Colts blog!

by 






























