Below is a write up on Luck from Jerry Angelo the former G.M. of the Bears. Angelo ranks him as the last Q.B. in the "Elite" category as in a Q.B. that improves a team and makes the team better than what it is. I have a hard time personally disagreeing with his write up.
If you’re in a ‘pick-up’ game, you’re picking him first. He plays with reckless abandon. He’ll have some ‘bonehead’ plays, but so did Favre. After watching him in the playoffs this year, he made some terrible decisions that led to turnovers. Yes, he responded well to those turnovers, but he put his team in major holes through turning over the football. He’s fearless and as he matures his game will improve. The only thing he’s missing is a championship ring.