Recap Week Two: Colts 22-Titans 20
![]() |
|
Photo (cropped): Colts.com |
Before I get into the nitty-gritty, I want to make a point here, and it's a point I've made over and over again: Vince Young is not that good of a QB, yet. No matter what evidence I unveil, no matter the support I get from others, people defend Vince Young and his mediocre play with an almost religious ferocity. They attack my criticisms as if I'd just insulted Jesus or something. I don't know whether to laugh at them, or be fearful for my life.
Even some great folks here, like The Screening Jock's BSanders37s, disagree with my take on Vince:
- Let's also be realistic about something else: The Colts gift wrapped this game for the Titans. This should have been a 40-6 blowout. The Colts were dominating the Titans at the point of attack. Tennessee's run defense was putrid, but for some reason the Colts stopped running the ball in the second half. More on that in a second. Tennessee's offense was totally stuffed in the first half, managing just 6 points. Their defense was fortunate to escape the first half only giving up 16.
- The first half should have been closer if you're Tennessee, but after a first down scamper, Vince Young took offense to something Kelvin Hayden said to him out of bounds and tossed the ball at Kelvin's face. A ref was standing right there. Flag. 15 yard unsportsmanlike penalty on Vince. Instead of points, the Titans punt. That was dumb move #1 by Vince, folks. Leaders, REAL leaders, don't do dumb stuff like that in big football games. Have you ever seen Peyton, Brady, Palmer, or McNabb ever do anything like that, even as rookies or second-year guys? No. Why? Because they are real leaders, not the fake hype we're getting out of Tennessee.
- The second half came, and the Colts (and the refs) did their best to play Santa Claus for the Titans. Missed FGs, missed opportunities, penalties, and bad officiating (Reggie Wayne was interferred on the INT toss-- Walt Coleman strikes again!) practically hand the Titans the game. However, because the Titans offense is SO DUMBED DOWN, they only managed to score 14 points in the second half. They were down 19-6 and continued to run the football, not throw it. If not for Coleman's screw-up, and a good pick by the Titans defense, the Titans offense would never have gotten back in the game with the way they were operating.
- Peyton Manning has an "off day" completeing 66% of his passes for 312 yards, 1 Td, and 1 INT.
- The Colts played the game without Freddie Keiaho and Rob Morris. They took my advice (yippee!) and played Cover 3 all day though. The BSBD lived along the line of scrimmage. They practically dared the Titans to throw. But what did Tennessee do? Run. Run. Run. Run. Run. Run. Run. Run. Run. Run. At times, it looked like Tennessee was flat out scared to throw the ball, even though they were doing a good job containing the Colts pass rush.
- The Titans' average gain per passing play was a whopping 4.1 yards. For those of your scoring at home, THAT STINKS! Remember last week, when everyone made a big deal about how great the Colts were against Drew Brees? In that game, the Saints averaged 4.0 yards per pass attempt in that game. Yet, somehow, despite sucking as bad as Brees did last week, we get excuses for Vince. Sorry, not buying.
-

Vince Young can't figure out why BigBlueShoe won't worship at his feet.
Photo (cropped): Chris Graythen/Getty Images - I cannot say enough good things about Bob Sanders. He was all over the field Sunday. 2.5 sacks, and he was in Vince Young's grill usually when he blitzed. Outstanding.
- Great play by the Colts secondary and defensive pressure on the final drive. The Titans had to throw the ball on every down that drive, and it resulted in disaster. However, by then it was too late. I'm sure Titans fans had dreams of Rob Bironas knocking in another miracle FG. Sorry, I didn't. I knew, eventually, Vince Young would screw up. Why? Because he can't throw. Eventually, you have to make plays from the pocket throwing the football, especially in a two minute offense. The Colts defense on that drive contained Vince by effectively blitzing him and made him throw from the pocket lest he get sacked again by the BSBD. Several of those throws, including the one missed by Brandon Jones, were simply off their target. Yes folks, the Jones throw was way too high. He had to leave his feet even though he was standing still in a the soft spot of the zone. Had Jones caught it, Kelvin Hayden was right there to destroy him on the way down, likely resulting in an incompletion.
- The next play was dumb move #2 by Vince. It's 4th down. The Colts blitz. Vince is obviously flustered by the pressue, but rather than look down field, where his receivers are one-on-one with the corners (Hint: That's what you want as a QB), he tries to run. The Colts wrap him up. He tries to shovel pass it to his lineman, which is illegal. Lineman loses the ball. Fumble. Colts recover. Game over. That play, right there, defines Vince Young as an NFL QB.
This is why I am so steadfast in my analysis of Vince. He just simply does not know how to play QB in the NFL, and has made little to no progress from last year to now. Even Mike Florio felt compelled to chime in on Vince Young's dismal play Sunday, and why it is so important for him to learn how to play QB in the NFL:
Even though Young survived the incident, his luck is eventually going to run out. He has zero sensitivity to the importance of avoiding contact, as evidence by several plays on Sunday. On one long run, he never considered the possibility of sliding. On another, he dropped a shoulder into a defensive back at the sideline.
Sure, it's fun to watch it. And it's probably fun for Young to do it. But it won't be fun for anyone once he suffers a broken ankle, a fractured femur, or the torn ligament trifecta.
And unless Young changes his ways one of those things eventually will happen.
Folks, if I sound too negative about Tennessee, it's not because I have anything personally against them. I just think they are all hype and no real substance. This is not a young football team. This is a veteran team that happens to have a second-year QB that has made no progression from year one to year two. If you're going to talk a lot about how you're ready for the next step and how you feel confident that you can take down the defending Champs despite the fact that those defending Champs OWN YOU, you damn well better back it up. Tennessee, per usual, does a lot of talking and not a lot of winning. They simply don't deserve the hype until they actually DO SOMETHING.
Teams like Houston, who has looked great in Weeks One and Two, deserve the hype. They are truly up-and-coming. Not this Titans team. That said, big props go to Titans fans for being fanatical about their team, in particular Jimmy and hartley over at Music City Miracles. The Colts are now 2-0, and despite playing a very imperfect game, came away with a road division win. They got ZERO of those last year.
Go Colts!
0 recs |
15 comments
Comments
Everyone has their own view on VY...
Oh, and how many people think Tom Moore watched last night's game with a smile on his face? "So that's how you're going to defend a spread offense, Norv? Huh. Guess we have one less team to worry about."
by BSanders37 on
Sep 17, 2007 10:40 AM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Turner
by MasterRWayne on
Sep 17, 2007 11:47 AM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Cam Cameron
by MarkV0327 on
Sep 17, 2007 1:39 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
My turn to chime in.....
Vince Young is phenominally talented....physically. He is extremely hard to contain when he gets outside the pocket. He extends plays and it is so hard to keep him from picking up large chunks of yards when scrambling. Mentally, however he just doesn't have it. As a QB in the NFL you just cannot win consistently unless you can be proficient in the pocket. As BBS pointed out, the Colts were daring him to throw deep, but he only attempted to throw the ball further than 10 yards downfield a couple of times. Fisher knows that he is not accurate enough to be successful that way, and would turn the ball over.
As far as his leadership goes, I will never forget what I saw when Texas won the National Championship. The cameras focused on Vince standing on the bench professing his greatness to the crowd, instead of celebrating with his teammates. He acted like he just single handedly won the game. Even if he did (which he didn't) there are a bunch of other guys that all busted their butts doing their part to win as well, and he took all the credit. Leaders simply don't do that. True leaders like Manning and Brady deflect the recognition to their teammates every chance they get. That's why guys follow them into battle without a single reservation in their mind. How can you do that with a guy who so obviously only cares about himself?
OK...I'm done...ready to move on to this weeks game.
by rudy0498 on
Sep 17, 2007 11:59 AM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Excellent comment
by BigBlueShoe on
Sep 17, 2007 12:07 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
How about?
by MasterRWayne on
Sep 17, 2007 12:24 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Wow.
But your "analysis" is so wrong it defies description.
But, since you are now responding to people who disagree with you with grade-school insults like "ball washing", I won't go into detail.
Not only are you a jerk, and wrong, you're unprofessional, too. Great.
F*ck you, I'm done here.
by hartley on
Sep 17, 2007 12:34 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
BON
Calling me an asshole and then storming off makes you look like nothing more than a sore loser.
by BigBlueShoe on
Sep 17, 2007 12:52 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Don't let the door hit ya...
That was a nice rebuttal. I would have liked to hear his own analysis instead.
by will on
Sep 17, 2007 1:31 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
No Kidding!
by MasterRWayne on
Sep 17, 2007 1:33 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
VY
He is still a qb learning the game (note wonder lick score, the guy is not smart) and hopefully will progress with time, because he is too physically gifted to be this bad of a passer. I totally agree that VY gets way too much hype, no QB should ever make the pro bowl with the kind of passing percentage he got, let alone win rookie of the year (especially with some of the rookies we had in the AFC last year). But lets not blame him for losing the game.
VY didn't win the game yesterday, but just like he didn't win it, he definately did not lose it.
Since we are getting technical, this is my opinion.
by Burt Doyle on
Sep 17, 2007 6:05 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Agreed on all points
I still think Young will be a pretty good QB in the future. He won't be Manning (then again, who is?) but he'll be good.
by JakeTheSnake on
Sep 17, 2007 9:56 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Bob Sanders
November can't get here soon enough. We're going to stomp them, I can feel it.
by BSanders37 on
Sep 17, 2007 6:08 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
please just stick with analyzing the colts
"This is not a young football team"
Over half of the players on the Titans roster are 1st or 2nd year guys.
Statistically there are few (if any) NFL teams that are younger than the Titans. But maybe you just don't think any team in the NFL is a "young" team.
Look, you guys won the game. Congrats.
But your analysis on the Tennessee side of things is god awful. Sometimes not factual. And most of the time blinded.
We understand you don't like Vince Young. I don't like Peyton. Vince throws for over 60% with a QB over 90 and somehow it proves how bad he is.
The game should have been 40-6?
The Titans haven't proven anything?
Vince Young simply hasn't performed well in some time, and how can anyone be impressed with his play of late?
Your ridiculous...Please stick with analyzing and giving opinions on the Clots....your only making yourself look like an idiot talking about the Titans...
by zackmann on
Sep 18, 2007 9:11 AM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Sorry, but
The Titans have a ton of young guys sitting the bench though, which is why they are (statistically) one of the younger teams in football. However, none of these guys see the field. Tennessee has 3 rookie WRs on the active roster, and none see the field. In terms of youth at the skill positions, only Vince Young and LenDale White (who splits carries with veteran Chris Brown) are the only young players worth a damn. Your pick from 2002 (Haynesworth) continues to stink. He was pushed around all day Sunday by a Colts team that's suposed to be "soft." Oh, and he likes to step on people.
The point here is while you have a lot of youth sitting on your bench, the people actually PLAYING are in fact veterans of several NFL seasons. When you are leaning on Nick Harper as your best corner, Eric Moulds as your best receiver, and Kevin Mawae as your best o-lineman, your team is not a "young" team.
Contrast this with the Colts: Their veteran in the secondary is Bob Sanders (year four). They had a 2nd year guy at LBer. Freeney (year 6) is the vet on the d-line. On offense, Marvin Harrison (who defies age) is the lone multi-year veteran. Jeff Saturday (year 9) is the vet on an o-line that has many young faces. They start a WR as a rookie. Their RB is in year two. His back-up is a rookie. Dallas Clark, year 5.
No, your starting team is not young. Perhaps you should take a closer look at your roster before bashing my opinions. It helps to know BEFORE you try and show me up.
And no, the Titans havn't proven anything. If they win the AFC South, if the win a playoff game, hell if they even MAKE the playoffs-- that's proving something. You're now in year 4 of no playoff appearances. That means your team sucks, and has sucked for some time. Until your team makes the playoffs, they haven't done jack flipin' squat.
That's no offesne, zackman. It's the reality of pro football.
by BigBlueShoe on
Sep 18, 2007 11:36 AM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs













