clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Manning doesn't want to sit

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

With the AFC South clinched and the #2 seed locked up in the playoffs, the Colts have absolutely nothing to play for against the last two opponents on the regular season schedule: Houston and Tennessee. This is in stark contrast to last season, where the Colts had to win the final game of the season against the Dolphins to lock up the #3 seed. If history is any indicator, Tony Dungy will now start pulling starters and conceding games. Yes, when you pull players who SHOULD play for players who never do, that is conceding the game.

Peyton Manning will have none of it, apparently:

Colts quarterback Peyton Manning, who doesn't like to sit under any circumstances, already has begun campaigning to stay on the field, noting he needs more time with the newer players. He made it clear, he's working on the assumption that Marvin Harrison won't return. Next week or this season.

"This is not the time to sit back,'' Manning said. "This is the time to keep going, in my opinion. I've already told (quarterbacks coach) Jim Caldwell. I need more time with these new players.''

He was asked if he feared a repeat of 2005. That year, the Colts clinched everything after 13 games, played their starters in a loss to San Diego, then sat their front-line people the last two regular season games.

"I certainly would not like that to be the case,'' Manning said unflinchingly. "The coaches will meet and come up with a plan, but with the new players, the more game experience, the better. I'd like to be in there the entire game next week.''

If history is an indicator, that's going to be a tough sell. Dungy has never bought the notion that the Colts lost to Pittsburgh in the 2005 playoffs because of the long layoff. If he sits Manning and the starters, they won't be happy, but it's not a coach's job to keep everybody happy. He can't afford to lose a front-liner -- especially Manning -- in a game that means nothing.

I've often questioned Dungy only to find myself dead wrong on numerous occasions, but here I have to agree with Manning. I don't want starters sitting. Sure, guys like Mathis, Harrison, and maybe Diem can sit until the playoffs, but the others should still play. Manning needs more time with Gonzo. Ugoh still needs more reps. Hagler should have at least two more full games. EVERYONE on special teams should play. They simply haven't earned the right to rest.

I think it's a mistake if Dungy starts resting starters.