My Team
QB David "Silky" Garrard
RB Brian Westbrook
RB Joseph Addai
RB Marion Barber
FB Madison Hedgecock
TE Antonio Gates
TE Chris Cooley
WR Marques Colston
WR Anquan Boldin
WR Anthony Gonzalez
WR Brandon Marshall
WR Roy Hall
OT Tony Ugoh
OT David Diehl
OG Kyle Kosier
OG Eric Heitmann
OC Dan Koppen
OC/G Dylan Gandy
OG Scott Wells
OT Kevin Shaffer
OL Micheal Toudouze
DE Dwight Freeney
DE Jared Allen
DT Raheem Brock
DT Corey Williams
DT Justin Tuck
DT Quinn Pitcock
DE Aaron Kampman
DE Robert Mathis
DE/DT Keyunta Dawson
DE/OLB Shaun Phillips
OLB Lance Briggs
MLB Gary Brackett
OLB Micheal Boley
LB Freddie Keiaho
LB Tyjuan Hagler
LB Clint Sessions
CB Asante Samuel
CB Nathan Vasher
CB Marlin Jackson
CB Dante Hughes
CB TJ Rushing
CB Micheal Coe
FS Antonie Bethea
SS Bob Sanders
S Matt Giordano
S Brandon Condren
K Steven Gostkowski
P Andy Lee
RET Josh Cribbs
That's all 50 Colts draft picks under Dungy
I'll fill out the roster with three undrafted FAs from those drafts
DT Ed Johnson
QB Tony Romo
OT Jason Peters
All the notables available at each pick are after the jump
2002
Colts Pick Dwight Freeney
- #14 TE Jeremy Shockey -1 All Pro, 4 Pro Bowls, 4234 yards, 27 TDs, one Superbowl spent getting drunk in a luxury box while his team wins, not the biggest ass among TEs named Jeremy (Jerramy) drafted in the 2002 first round.
- #15 DT Albert Haynesworth -1 AP, 1 PB, 15.5 sacks, one Cowboys' player's face stomped on.
- # 20 WR Javon Walker -1 PB, 3947 yards, 31 TDs
- #24 S Ed Reed -3 AP 4 PB, 34 INTs, 308 tackles, 6 year starter
- #26 CB Lito Sheppard -1 AP, 2 PB, 17 INTs
- #37 C Andre Gurode- 2PB, 5 year starter, recipient of one Albert Haynesworth face stomp
Colts Pick (Larry Tripplett)
- #44 C LeCharles Bentley -2 PB, 4 year starter
- #52 RB Clinton Portis -1 PB, 9403 yards, 67 TDs
- #58 S Michael Lewis -1 PB, 11 INTs, 7.5 sacks, 400 tackles
- #65 WR Deion Branch- 5 year starter, SB MVP, 4171 yards, 22 TDs
Colts Pick Joe Jefferson
- #89 LB Akin Ayodele - 5 year starter, 9.5 sacks, 5 INTs, 379 tackles
- #91 RB Brian Westbrook -1 AP, 2 PB, 7992 yards, 50 TDs
- #104 DE Alex Brown -31.5 sacks, 4 INTs, 5 year starter
- #105 CB Brian Williams -6 year starter, 16 INTs, 4 sacks, 301 tackles
Colts Pick (David Thornton)
- #108 QB David Garrard- 6052 yards passing, over 2:1 TD:INT, 822 rushing yards, 43 total TDs.
- #114 TE Randy McMichael- 6 year starter, 3533 yards, 21 TDs
- #141 LB Andra Davis - 5 year starter, 7 INTs, 8.5 sacks, 388 tackles
- #143 LB Scott Fujita- 6 year starter, 18 sacks, 3 iNTs, 412 tackles
- #156 DE Aaron Kampman - 2 PB, 244 tackles, 41 sacks,
- #157 DB Jermaine Phillips - 5 year starter, 8 INTs, 3 sacks, 284 tackles
3 Colts picks
- #187 C Justin Hartwig- 4 year starter
- #199 RB Adrian Peterson- 1741 yards, 8 TDs
- #207 RB Chester Taylor- 4965 yards, 20 TDs
- # 210 TE Bryan Fletcher- Will make the Colts roster as a free agent
Colts Pick (Josh Mallard)
- #235 WR Ronald Curry- 2170 yards, 11 TDs
- #238 DE-DT Raheem Brock- 5 year starter for Colts, 21.5 sacks
- #239 G Eric Heitmann- 5 year starter
- #245 T Kevin Shaffer- 4 year starter
- #253 G Kyle Kosier- 5 year starter
2003
Colts Pick Dallas Clark
- #27 Larry Johnson- 1 All Pro, 2 PB, 5983 yards, 56 TDs
- #39 Rashean Mathis- 1 AP, 1 PB, 21 INTs, 294 tackles
- #42 Ken Hamlin- 1 PB, 13 INTs, 4 sacks, 284 tackles
- #54 Anquan Boldin- 2 PB, 5588 yards, 29 TDs
- #56 Osi Umenyiora- 1 AP, 2 PB, 41.5 sacks
Colts Pick (Mike Doss)
- #68 Lance Briggs- 1 AP, 3 PB, 5 year starter, 6 INTs, 5.5 sacks, 446 tackles
- #69 Jason Witten- 1 AP, 4 PB, 3983 yards, 21 TDs
Colts Pick (Donald Strickland)
- #96 Justin Fargas- 1 year starter, 2383 yards, 6 TDs
- #111 Terrence McGee- 1 PB, 13 INTs, 5 KR TDs
- #120 Asante Samuel- 1 AP, 1 PB, 22 INTs, 211 tackles
Colts Pick (Steve Sciullo)
- #124 Brandon Lloyd- 1889 yards, 13 TDs
- #125 Ike Taylor- 7 INTs, 1 sack, 240 tackles
- #134 Ovie Mughelli- Awesome name, 3 year starter at FB, 288 yards, 3 TDs
- #137 Terrence Holt- 8 INTs, 189 tackles, 0.5 sack
Colts Pick (Robert Mathis)
- #149 Mike Scifres 4 year starter as a punter
- #160 David Diehl 5 year starter, started seasons at LG, RG, RT and LT.
Colts Pick (Keyon Whiteside)
- #164 Dan Koppen- 5 year starter, 1 PB
- #166 Hunter Hillenmeyer- 4 year starter, 211 tackles, 3.5 sacks, 1 INT
- #168 Sean Mahan- 3 year starter
- #177 Reggie Wells- 4 year starter
2 Colts Picks (Cato June, Makoa Freitas)
- #211 David Tyree- one of the most amazing/important catches in NFL History, 641 yards, 4 TDs, 1 Pro Bowl as a special teams coverage specialist.
- #222 Josh Brown 5 year starter, franchise tagged kicker.
- Undrafted Antonio Gates- 3 AP, 4 PB, 4362 yards, 43 TDs
- Undrafted Tony Romo- 2 PB, 55 passing TDs, 7114 passing yards
- Undrafted Gary Brackett
2004
Colts Pick Bob Sanders
- #64 DT Darnell Dockett- 1 PB, 3 INT, 15 sacks, 4 year starter
- #65 K Nate Kaeding- 1 PB, Highest career FG% in NFL history
- #66 C Nick Hardwick- 1 PB, 4 year starter
Two Colts Picks (Ben Hartsock, Gilbert Gardner)
- #81 TE Chris Cooley- 1 PB, Captain Chaos, 2608 yards, cashed $9 million signing bonus check at bank drive-through, 27 TDs, took in-laws to a strip club
- #84 OT Sean Locklear- 3 year starter
- #94 OT Travelle Wharton- 3 year starter
- #96 LB Landon Johnson- 4 year starter
- #98 DE/OLB Shaun Phillips- 31 sacks, 3 INTs
- #101 LB Demorrio Williams- 3 year starter, 5 INTs, 6.5 sacks
Colts Pick (Kendyll Pope)
- #108 WR Jerricho Cotchery- 2469 yards, 8 TDs
- #110 CB Nathan Vasher- 1 PB, 17 INTs
- #117 DE Robert Geathers- 20.5 sacks, 2 INTs
Colts Pick (Jason David)
- #126 DE Jared Allen- 1 AP, 1 PB, 43 sacks, 3 DUIs, 4 year starter
- #136 DB Gibril Wilson- 4 year starter, 11 INTs, 6 sacks
- #157 K Josh Scobee- 4 year starter
Colts Pick (Jake Scott)
- #154 RB Michael Turner- 1328 yards, 6 TDs, 1 undefeated Colts season ended.
- #156 FB Mike Karney- 4 year starter, 5 TDs
Colts Pick (Von Hutchins)
- #179 DT Corey Williams- 17 sacks, 1 INT
- #188 P Andy Lee- 1 AP, 1 PB, 4 year starter
Colts Pick (Jim Sorgi)
- #209 OT Shane Olivea- 4 year starter, currently unsigned and suspended for failing a drug test.
- #216 WR Patrick Crayton-Terry says he's good
Colts Pick (David Kimball)
- #249 DE Bobby McCray- 2 year starter, 22 sacks
- #251 OG Scott Wells -3 year starter
- Undrafted Willie Parker- 2 PB, 4818 yards, 23 TDs
2005
Colts Pick: CB Marlin Jackson- 3 INTs, 173 tackles, 2 year starter
OG Logan Mankins- 1 PB, 3 year starter
MLB Lofa Tatupu- 1 AP, 3 PB, 3 year starter, 8 INTs, 6.5 sacks, 262 tackles
RET Justin Miller- 1 PB, 3 KR TD, 2938 return yards
Colts Pick: Kelvin Hayden- 3 INTs, 118 tackles, 1 year starter
HB Frank Gore- 1 PB, 4457 yards, 18 TDs
LB Kirk Morrison- 3 year starter, 289 tackles, 6 INTs, 2 sacks
CB Ellis Hobbs- 3 year starter, 6 INTs, 2 KR TD
DT/DE Justin Tuck- 10 sack season as DT/reserve DE
Colts Pick: Vincent Burns- 0 games played
HB Marion Barber- 1 PB, 33 TDs, 2760 yards
HB Brandon Jacobs- 1854 yards, 22 TDs, Kenton Keithesque receiving
S Kerry Rhodes- 3 year starter, 10 INT, 8 sacks, 213 tackles
Colts Pick: Dylan Gandy- 1 year starter
RET Darren Sproles- 2 RET TD, 2536 return yards
Colts Pick: Matt Giordano- 3 INTs, 45 tackles, blazing fast
DE Trent Cole- 1 PB, 25,5 sacks, 1 INT, 2 year starter
Colts Pick: Jonathan Welsh- 6 games played
LB Michael Boley- 3 year starter, 204 tackles, 4 INTs, 6 sacks
Colts Pick: Tyjuan Hagler- 43 tackles 1 sack
TE Bo Scaife- 2 year starter, 1077 yards, 6 TDs
DB Chris Harris- 3 year starter, 168 tackles, 6 INTs
Colts Pick: Dave Rayner- 2 year starter
QB Derek Anderson- 1 PB, 4580 pass yards, 34 TDs, TD:INT>1
CB Reynaldo Hill- 2 year starter, 6 INTs, 94 tackles
Colts Pick: Anthony Davis- 0 games played
FB Madison Hedgecock- 2 year starter
RET Josh Cribbs- 1 PB, 5 RET TD, 5065 return yards
2006
Colts pick: Joseph Addai- 1 PB, 2742 yards, 23 TDs
DeMeco Ryans- 1 PB, 225 tackles, 2 INTs, 5.5 sacks
Marcus McNeill- 2 PB, 2 year starter at LT
Greg Jennings- 1552 yards, 15 TDs
Devin Hester-2 AP, 2 PB, 11 RET TD, 3002 return yards, 2 recieving TDs
Maurice Jones-Drew- 2552 yards, 24 TDs, 2 RET TDs, 4264 return yards.
Colts Pick: Tim Jennings- 37 tackles
Jason Spitz- 2 year starter at G
Jerious Norwood-1625 yards, 3 TDs, 6.2 YPC
Colts Pick: Freddie Keiaho- 1 year starter, 80 tackles, 1 INT, 0.5 sacks
Owen Daniels- 2 year starter, 1120 yards, 8 TDs
Leon Washington- 1486 yards, 7 TDs, 4.5 YPC, 3 RET TDs, 3136 return yards
Brandon Marshall- 1703 yards, 9 TDs
Elvis Dumervil- 21 sacks, 29 games played
Mark Anderson- 17 sacks
Stephen Gostkowski- Elite kickoff specialist, NFL level accuracy
Colts Pick: Michael Toudouze -2nd best LT on the 2007 Colts, 5 games played
Colts Pick: Charlie Johnson -30 games played, maybe he'll be a good guard
Sam Koch- 2 year starter at P, one of three 2 year starters drafted after the 5th round.
Colts Pick: Antoine Bethea -1 PB, 113 tackles, 5 INTs, 2 year starter
Colts Pick: T.J. Rushing- 1 RET TD, 1044 return yards
Marques Colston- 2240 yards, 19 TDs, 2 year starter
2007
I'll leave Polian's picks alone with only one year to evaluate off of.