clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Rebuilding Jim Irsay’s Glory Days Dream Teams; Trimming the Roster

After we’ve gone through our simulated offseason, what would the Colts’ 2018 Week 1 roster look like?

Jacksonville Jaguars v Indianapolis Colts Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images

We complete this series with Part 5, taking a look at how the Colts can sculpt their roster down to 53 players before the 2018 season.

I fully believe that owner Jim Irsay, general manager Chris Ballard and the Indianapolis Colts are on the way back to some semblance of the team’s 2000’s glory days, so I wanted to put together this project where I see what the Colts can do to get back to Irsay’s favorite era — the Peyton Manning glory days.

No one can snap their fingers and make this team completely constructed in just one offseason. Rome wasn’t built in a day. Players take time to develop. It also needs to be appreciated just how special those Manning-led teams were. They did things that we may never see again, and that’s okay.

What these Colts can do is continue to build a foundation to try and start another quasi-dynasty.


We’ve now gone through the entire offseason (see below) and now it’s time to make the tough calls and get this roster ready for Week 1 of the 2018 regular season. Take it with a grain of salt because undrafted free agent and training camp/preseason roster turnover was not factored in. This was just based off of moves made following free agency and the 2018 NFL Draft.

After adding the players that were signed and re-signed in free agency, plus the draft picks, here is what the roster would hypothetically look like when cut down to 53 players.

Projection of the Colts’ 2018 lineup (sorry for the small size)

For those who couldn’t see the font in the photo, here is the lineup:

  • QB — Andrew Luck, Jacoby Brissett
  • RB — Marlon Mack, Ronald Jones II, Robert Turbin
  • WR — TY Hilton, Allen Robinson, Donte Moncrief, Chester Rogers, Cedrick Wilson
  • TEJack Doyle, Erik Swoope, Darrell Daniels, Ross Travis
  • OTAnthony Castonzo, Chukwuma Okorafor, Le’Raven Clark, Denzelle Good
  • OG — Andrew Norwell, Jack Mewhort, Joe Haeg, Deyshawn Bond
  • C — Ryan Kelly , Anthony Fabiano
  • DE — Jabaal Sheard, Bradley Chubb, Tarell Basham, Barkevious Mingo, Mike Love
  • DT — Johnathan Hankins, Henry Anderson, Al Woods, Margus Hunt, Hassan Ridgeway, Grover Stewart
  • SAM — John Simon
  • WILL — Anthony Walker, Tegray Scales
  • MIKEPreston Brown, Edwin Jackson
  • CBQuincy Wilson, Pierre Desir, Nate Hairston, Kenny Moore, Holton Hill
  • S — Malik Hooker, Clayton Geathers, Matthias Farley, T.J. Green, Jarrod Franklin
  • K — Adam Vinatieri
  • P — Rigoberto Sanchez
  • LS — Luke Rhodes

Keep in mind that some of these depth pieces don’t matter right now because the bottom of a roster changes so drastically over the course of an offseason.


  • QBBrad Kaaya, Phillip Walker
  • RBJosh Ferguson
  • WRKrishawn Hogan, K.J. Brent, Kolby Listenbee, Dres Anderson, Justice Liggins, James Wright, Seantavius Jones
  • TEJason Vander Laan, Mo Alie-Cox
  • OLTyreek Burwell, Mark Glowinski, Isaiah Williams

There is nothing really surprising here. These are mostly the names that you would expect to see cut, some of them making their way to the practice squad. With Brissett staying on board and not being traded, Kaaya is relegated to the practice squad. Alie-Cox continues his training to be the Colts’ next basketball player turned tight end as well.


  • DLCaraun Reid, Joey Mbu, Anthony Johnson, Arthur Miley, Johnathan Calvin
  • LBAntonio Morrison, Darnell Sankey, Joshua Perry, Jermaine Grace
  • CB — D.J. White
  • SRonald Martin

It’s time for Morrison to be replaced. I made it a focal point in this offseason, adding Brown and Scales. Jackson was the better of the two when Morrison and Jackson started at inside linebacker for the Colts in 2016, so Jackson gets his spot back. Walker is probably a better option too.


Italicized players have been re-signed in this exercise.

  • QB — Scott Tolzien
  • RB — Frank Gore, Matt Jones, Christine Michael, George Winn
  • WRDonte Moncrief, Kamar Aiken
  • TEErik Swoope, Brandon Williams
  • OLJack Mewhort, Jeremy Vujnovich, Mike Person
  • EDBarkevious Mingo
  • LBJon Bostic, Edwin Jackson
  • DB — Rashaan Melvin, Darius Butler, Pierre Desir, Chris Milton
  • STAdam Vinatieri, Luke Rhodes