clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Colts reportedly trying to talk Adam Vinatieri out of retirement

The Colts aren’t ready to give up on the NFL’s oldest player.

NFL: Indianapolis Colts at Los Angeles Chargers Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

Indianapolis Colts kicker Adam Vinatieri has had an eventful regular season to say the least. The future hall of fame kicker has struggled through his first two games, which has lead to speculation of an imminent retirement.

However, according to Mike Florio the Colts aren’t ready to give up on “the GOAT.” NBC sports reports:

“Per a source with knowledge of the situation, the Colts aren’t ready to give up on Vinatieri, and they hope to persuade him to stay. Either way, they expect to have an answer by Monday afternoon.”

Some may raise the question: Why would the team still want Vinatieri on the roster after two consecutive bad outings?

This is a valid question, but it appears the team’s thought process may be: What current free agent kicker would you replace him with? The 46 year-old has been consistent his entire career, and finding someone at or above his level may be difficult.

Either way the team will be taking a risk. You can sign a kicker who wasn’t good enough to make 31 other teams, or you go with the guy who’s made a living knocking down clutch kicks for 24 years, but now is going through a rough streak at 46 years old.

That said, this is the dilemma that the Colts are tasked with. And if the reports are true, the team is trying to go with what they know.